Best Safety Shoes – 2021 Editor’s Guide

If you work in a physically demanding job, you shouldn’t have to worry about your safety. But to remain safe on the job, you have to take precautions and that might mean wearing safety or steel-toed footwear.

As you can probably guess, the purpose of safety shoes is to guard your toes – the most vulnerable part of your foot – against heavy falling objects, compression, or anything on the ground that might cut through the footwear.

If you're looking to keep your toes safe while you're at work or out enjoying your favorite hobby, look no further than this guide.

The steel-toe version of your best safety trainers will keep you from injuring yourself, and help you perform better overall.

Standout Picks

Caterpillar Men's Second Shift Steel Toe Work Boot
Heavy duty and practically oozing seriousness, the Caterpillar Second Shit could follow you into the depths of the earth and return unscathed. On the outside, it's all leathery toughness, but on the inside, it's just generous plush and a fancy lining specially designed to cool off your feet in warm areas. You don't get much more pampered than this, that's for sure.
KEEN Utility Men's Atlanta Cool 2 Low Steel Toe Work Shoe
Lightweight, ventilated, dense and with a molded insole, a padded collar, and top-notch traction rubber on the bottom - the Keen Atlanta Cool will get you through the work day and still leave you feeling fresh after you clock out. It's also capable of guarding you against electrical hazards and slips, in addition to the standard characteristics of a steel toe box.
Timberland PRO Men's 6" Pit Boss Steel Toe Industrial Work Boot
Ready to work? So is the Timberland 6" Pit Boss. It's every bit as sturdy and no-nonsense as it looks. In addition to the expected steel toe box and midsole plate, this design is made out of leather, known for its durability and resistance to damage. The padded collar not only provides even more protection, but it promises that you'll be comfortable as well. This design gets down to business.
Skechers for Work Men's Synergy Ekron Alloy Toe Work Shoe
Skechers footwear is trusted by millions across the globe because of the comfort, durability, and style of their designs. The Synergy Ekron is built with the working class in mind. It offers a lightweight composite toe and electrical resistance. When looking for comfort, look towards Skechers. The use of a memory foam footbed will keep your feet feeling great, even after long hours.
Amazon Link
Thorogood Crosstrex Safety Toe
Made of leather for hardiness, mesh for keeping out debris and facilitating coolness, and a rubber sole for helping you stay upright even on the slippery ground, the Thorogood Crosstex can be your best friend in diverse environments, especially warm ones. It is every bit as sensible as it looks, and together with the standard steel toe and midsole plate, it is highly reliable in any work situation.
Amazon Link
Timberland PRO Men's, Powertrain Sport Alloy Toe SD+ Work Shoe
Timberland is a powerhouse in this category and that is easily seen with how many spots they earned in our guide. The Powertrain Sport gives you an abrasion-resistant upper, an alloy protective toe, and the ability to dissipate static. In addition to all of this, you won't have to worry about lasting foul odors or discomfort in your footwear. It is to work and to please. Timberland is without a doubt the best safety shoe brand on the market.
KEEN Utility Men's Flint 2 Low Steel Toe Non Slip Work Shoe
It resists oil spills, bad foot odor, and water and moisture both without and within. On the other hand, the Keen Flint Low delivers arch support, security, and comfort. This design basically has everything figured out. Wear it for your work or hobbies all day long, then take it off with the happy knowledge that your feet have never felt better.
Timberland PRO Men's 53534 TiTAN Safety-Toe Slip-On Loafer
Here's a design for someone who works hard in the rough terrain but also likes maintaining a sense of classiness and style. If not for the steel toe box and ridged rubber sole, you might think that this was an office shoe. Not only does the Titan Alloy give you a snazzy flair while keeping you safe, but it's also designed to feel as good as it looks.
Reebok Work Men's Sublite Cushion Work RB4041
When we think of the Reebok name, we don't usually think of protective footwear. In recent years, many brands are branching out and trying to meet the needs of a wider variety of clientele. The Subtle Cushion Work is breathable and flexible yet still offers great toe protection and protection from electrical hazards. In addition to all of this, it also offers you a slip-resistant outsole.

Criteria Used for Evaluation

Safety Hazards

Different jobs require different features when it comes to your footwear.

Some jobs, like logging, may require just a steel toe, while other jobs, like being a machinist may, require a puncture-proof plate and a steel toe.

Whatever your need may be, there is certainly a design out there to meet the requirement of your job. Before purchasing a new pair for work you will want to check what criteria is needed. You certainly don’t want to buy a pair to find out they are lacking something that is required.

Oftentimes, you will see a symbol rather than words for what the footwear is resistant to. This can be confusing but it is very important to understand. Again, purchasing something that isn’t approved for the task you are going to perform is not only a waste of time but also a major waste of money. Let’s take a look at the different features and symbols you will come into contact with.

  • Green Triangle:
    The green triangle means that the footwear has a grade 1 toe cap and a puncture-resistant plate lining the bottom. This is ideal for construction environments, where the bottom of your footwear may come in contact with broken glass, nails, or other sharp debris.
  • Yellow Triangle:
    The yellow triangle means the design has a grade 2 toe cap and puncture-resistant plate. These are better suited for light industry as they offer less protection than models with a green triangle.
  • White Square with an Orange OHM Symbol:
    This symbol means the footwear offers electrical protection. If you work in an environment where there are live wires or a chance of coming in contact with electricity, this is certainly something you will need in your footwear.
  • Yellow Square with a Green SD and Grounding Symbol:
    These shoes will offer static resistance. They reduce static charge in high-static areas. If static discharge is in the environment that you are in, this will surely be a standard for employment.
  • Red Square with Black C and Grounding Symbol:
    This type of footwear has a sole that is electrically conductive. You will need this if you work in a situation where you may be exposed to low electrical charges.
  • White Square with a Pine Tree:
    If you work with chainsaws, then these are the boots you are going to need. They offer resistance to cutting equipment that is found in this type of work.
  • Blue Square with a White Circle and Letter R:
    This footwear will offer class one toe protection, however, it does not offer any sole protection. These will fit in a manufacturing situation, where you don’t have to worry about the bottom of your footwear being punctured.
  • Gray Square with a Black Circle and Letter R:
    These offer a class two toe protector. They do not offer any sole protection, so they will be better for a light duty protective toe need.

Regardless of your need for protection, know there are many good options out there. Too much protection is better than not enough. Knowing what you are looking at when reading the symbols will be very beneficial during your hunt for the best choice for yourself.

Comfort

If you find yourself on your feet a lot, you know that this can cause pain and discomfort if you are wearing ill-fitting or poorly built footwear.

Standing all day can also lead to leg and back pain. Finding footwear that offers features of comfort or customization makes wearing your footwear long day after long day much more bearable.

There are a few different things that should be considered when looking at the overall comfort of your footwear, one of which we will explore in this section, and that is the footbed.

The footbed is the part of footwear that comes in direct contact with your foot sole. It can be removable or fixed, and if you want maximum comfort, you definitely want it to be cushioned. Not too much, but enough to keep your steps soft and bouncy.

The footbed can also be contoured, or molded, which is a great support feature. The contours of the footbed should fit the forms of your feet, and they will keep excess pressure off of the key points on your sole. Molded footbeds usually also come with arch support, which is essential if you want to stave off foot fatigue at the end of a long day.

The other three comfort features deserve their own sections, and those are the materials the design is made of, breathability and flexibility. Let's see what these have to offer!

Materials

Outsole:
When it comes to the outsole, different materials absorb and distribute impact differently. Rubber is most commonly used and does a fairly good job of dispersing shock. Rubber is also decently flexible This allows your foot to move more naturally and will, in turn, have you feeling less pain.

Insole:
In the category of comfort, the insole is probably the most important aspect. There are a variety of materials for insoles, with EVA foam and its varieties being the most common ones. They do a great job at conforming to the foot and absorbing shock.

It is important to note, that finding a design with a removable insole can be crucial to your comfort if you wear a custom orthotic or special insert. Another advantage of a removable insole is the longevity of use. Oftentimes due to the durable nature of this type of product, the interior of the shoe will wear before the exterior. The ability to simply replace the insole saves you time and money.

Upper Material:
You most often see the upper of protective footwear to be leather. You may also find synthetic blends and different textile materials mixed in. A solid leather design is flexible and breathable yet also durable at the same time. Synthetic blends wear quicker but can offer better flexibility and added comfort.

Those that use fabric in their models are offering better breathability and added flexibility. This, however, may reduce the overall protection and durability.

Flexibility

When considering comfort, you also need to take flexibility into account.

How footwear moves will greatly impact how you feel at the end of the day.

You don't want to feel restricted in any way. Your ankle should have no problems rotating in every direction, and the toe box and the outsole of the design shouldn't hinder your movements. Flexibility is key if you wish to maintain a natural gait and to avoid suffering from pain and fatigue when you come home.

Due to the more rigid nature of this type of footwear, finding an option that offers adequate protection yet is also flexible, can feel impossible. However, rest assured that in our guide we offer more than enough options that are flexible and protective at the same time. Simply sort the items by the Flexibility criterion, and choose off the top of the list! It's as easy as that!

Breathability

The last criterion we thought about when looking into important features was the overall breathability.

Hot, sweaty feet can lead to a variety of problems. You will be constantly battling unpleasant odor, and you will be susceptible to bacterial or fungal growth, rubbed, raw skin, and blisters. Wearing footwear that breathes will keep your feet dry.

A breathable upper paired with a liner that wicks sweat is the perfect option. A mixture of tough leather and some textile will increase breathability and keep your feet cool while not sacrificing durability and protection.

It is important to note that the socks you wear also play a huge role in how dry your feet stay during a long afternoon. Try to avoid pure cotton, as it tends to absorb moisture and remain damp until you dry it out. Instead go for wool or bamboo socks, which have superior properties in every way.

Best Safety Toe Shoes Reviews in 2021

1. Caterpillar Second Shift

Where to buy
Caterpillar Men's Second Shift Steel Toe Work Boot
Caterpillar Men's Second Shift Steel Toe Work Boot
Caterpillar Men's Second Shift Steel Toe Work Boot
Amazon Link

Heavy duty and practically oozing seriousness, the Caterpillar Second Shit could follow you into the depths of the earth and return unscathed. On the outside, it's all leathery toughness, but on the inside, it's just generous plush and a fancy lining specially designed to cool off your feet in warm areas. You don't get much more pampered than this, that's for sure.

The leather upper guarantees that the boot will not easily fall apart, but the plush around the collar and the lining on the insole assure that the designers were thinking of your comfort as well. It's expected that the Second Shift will be your boot of choice when you have to walk on oil or other slick terrains, which is why it's been equipped with rubber slip-resistant soles that feature excellent traction.

This Caterpillar footwear option comes at a fairly wide range of costs, but at its lowest, it's almost a steal. At its most expensive, it's not ideal, but it's still great for what it can do.

2. Keen Atlanta Cool 2

Where to buy
KEEN Utility Men's Atlanta Cool 2 Low Steel Toe Work Shoe
KEEN Utility Men's Atlanta Cool 2 Low Steel Toe Work Shoe
KEEN Utility Men's Atlanta Cool 2 Low Steel Toe Work Shoe
Amazon Link

Lightweight, ventilated, dense and with a molded insole, a padded collar, and top-notch traction rubber on the bottom - the Keen Atlanta Cool will get you through the work day and still leave you feeling fresh after you clock out. It's also capable of guarding you against electrical hazards and slips, in addition to the standard characteristics of a steel toe box.

The main construction of the Atlanta Cool is fashioned from leather - an extremely durable material - and mesh, which keeps the feet clean and airy. Due to all the bells and whistles that keep you safe from harm, the Atlanta Cool promises security and protection for you while remaining lightweight, so you feel less tired at the end of the day.

This design is on the upper end of expensiveness, yes, but it can still be a great investment for anyone who wants an option with a bit of everything.

3. Timberland Pit Boss

Where to buy
Timberland PRO Men's 6" Pit Boss Steel Toe Industrial Work Boot
Timberland PRO Men's 6" Pit Boss Steel Toe Industrial Work Boot
Timberland PRO Men's 6" Pit Boss Steel Toe Industrial Work Boot
Amazon Link

Ready to work? So is the Timberland 6" Pit Boss. It's every bit as sturdy and no-nonsense as it looks. In addition to the expected steel toe box and midsole plate, this design is made out of leather, known for its durability and resistance to damage. The padded collar not only provides even more protection, but it promises that you'll be comfortable as well. This design gets down to business.

The steel toe box is not only present, as expected, but it leaves a bit of extra wiggle room for your toes. Combine that with the padded collar and the option to lace up the boot as tightly or as loosely as you wish, and the Pit Boss strikes the perfect balance between hardy and snug.

On top of fending off any possible injury from outside forces, this design is wonderfully shock-absorbent. Your foot will be nothing other than safe and healthy while inside it.

As far as a boot like this goes, the price is rather average and fairly reasonable, especially since a single pair should last you a long time and since these are one of the most comfortable steel toe shoes in the world.

4. Skechers Synergy Ekron

Where to buy
Amazon Link
Skechers for Work Men's Synergy Ekron Alloy Toe Work Shoe
Skechers for Work Men's Synergy Ekron Alloy Toe Work Shoe
Skechers for Work Men's Synergy Ekron Alloy Toe Work Shoe
Amazon Link

Skechers footwear is trusted by millions across the globe because of the comfort, durability, and style of their designs. The Synergy Ekron is built with the working class in mind. It offers a lightweight composite toe and electrical resistance. When looking for comfort, look towards Skechers. The use of a memory foam footbed will keep your feet feeling great, even after long hours.

Offering the same protection as a steel toe, the use of a composite blend in these safety shoes gives this design a lighter weight. In addition, the Ekron is very durable and non-metallic, meaning you won't have to worry about going through security at the airport if you happen to be wearing your work footwear.

The sole on the Ekron safety shoes will keep you planted firmly on your feet, helping you avoid serious injury.

Due to the fact that the brand Skechers is so popular, it is surprising how affordable this option is. Most budgets will be able to afford this superior protective design.

Amazon Link

5. Thorogood Crosstrex

Where to buy
Amazon Link
Thorogood Crosstrex Safety Toe
Amazon Link

Made of leather for hardiness, mesh for keeping out debris and facilitating coolness, and a rubber sole for helping you stay upright even on the slippery ground, the Thorogood Crosstex can be your best friend in diverse environments, especially warm ones. It is every bit as sensible as it looks, and together with the standard steel toe and midsole plate, it is highly reliable in any work situation.

This design thinks of more than just protecting your foot from getting crushed - it also knows that you work best when you're not distracted by a warm and moist foot. That's why it has mesh inserts in the upper, to keep the air flowing in and out of the design and keep your feet dry. On the Crosstex, it's not just the steel toe box that comes in handy.

Thanks to the rubber sole, it's less likely that you will slip and hurt yourself. You can also remove the footbed to put your own insert in its place, which is great if you have orthopedic needs or concerns. This option protects your foot's health as well!

Though the Thorogood Crosstex can certainly make a dent in your wallet, the price isn't bad for such great footwear - perhaps even slightly on the low end.

Amazon Link

6. Timberland Powertrain

Where to buy
Timberland PRO Men's, Powertrain Sport Alloy Toe SD+ Work Shoe
Timberland PRO Men's, Powertrain Sport Alloy Toe SD+ Work Shoe
Timberland PRO Men's, Powertrain Sport Alloy Toe SD+ Work Shoe
Amazon Link

Timberland is a powerhouse in this category and that is easily seen with how many spots they earned in our guide. The Powertrain Sport gives you an abrasion-resistant upper, an alloy protective toe, and the ability to dissipate static. In addition to all of this, you won't have to worry about lasting foul odors or discomfort in your footwear. It is to work and to please. Timberland is without a doubt the best safety shoe brand on the market.

The structure and design of this option is one that keeps your feet, legs, and back feeling great all day. The outsole of the Powertrain Sport is made of polyurethane which is great at absorbing shock. In addition, the design of the outsole is flexible and will move naturally with your feet, adding to the overall comfort level.

The mesh lining in the Powertrain Sport is treated to help stop odor and bacteria build-up. It will move moisture away from your feet and dry quickly so your feet will stay cool and comfortable. We all know how bad work footwear can smell and often it is still damp the next day. You won't have to worry about either of these things if you choose the Powertrain Sport.

The unique look and great design of this design fall in the middle of our pricing. Most budgets will be able to fit it in. You will get an extremely comfortable and forgiving pair of protective shoes that will do well in any casual environment.

7. Keen Flint Low 2

Where to buy
KEEN Utility Men's Flint 2 Low Steel Toe Non Slip Work Shoe
KEEN Utility Men's Flint 2 Low Steel Toe Non Slip Work Shoe
KEEN Utility Men's Flint 2 Low Steel Toe Non Slip Work Shoe
Amazon Link

It resists oil spills, bad foot odor, and water and moisture both without and within. On the other hand, the Keen Flint Low delivers arch support, security, and comfort. This design basically has everything figured out. Wear it for your work or hobbies all day long, then take it off with the happy knowledge that your feet have never felt better.

This design doesn't just think about how to keep you safe while on the job, it prepares for when you clock out, too. It's equipped with a CleanSport NXT to fight odor so that you get treated to a fresher smell at the end of the day than you would with most other options of this type.

The Keen Flint Low puts a special emphasis on water resistance. If you have to work somewhere that might require submerging your foot, this is a great choice for you.

You might say that it's a bit expensive for a shoe, but this isn't just any design. The price is a bit high, but the Keen Flint Low gives you a lot for every buck.

8. Timberland Titan Alloy

Where to buy
Timberland PRO Men's 53534 TiTAN Safety-Toe Slip-On Loafer
Timberland PRO Men's 53534 TiTAN Safety-Toe Slip-On Loafer
Timberland PRO Men's 53534 TiTAN Safety-Toe Slip-On Loafer
Amazon Link

Here's a design for someone who works hard in the rough terrain but also likes maintaining a sense of classiness and style. If not for the steel toe box and ridged rubber sole, you might think that this was an office shoe. Not only does the Titan Alloy give you a snazzy flair while keeping you safe, but it's also designed to feel as good as it looks.

This popular safety shoe brand is known for its PowerFit comfort system, which tells you that their designers can methodically research how best to keep your feet satisfied and free of pain.

Since the design looks so much classier than the average safety option, you can use it on multiple occasions and situations, meaning you get a lot of use for your money.

This kind of quality commands a high price. You'll need to be okay with shelling out a good amount of cash for the Titan Alloy, but if it's up to your alley, you'll be glad you did it.

9. Reebok Subtle Cushion Work

Where to buy
Reebok Work Men's Sublite Cushion Work RB4041
Reebok Work Men's Sublite Cushion Work RB4041
Reebok Work Men's Sublite Cushion Work RB4041
Amazon Link

When we think of the Reebok name, we don't usually think of protective footwear. In recent years, many brands are branching out and trying to meet the needs of a wider variety of clientele. The Subtle Cushion Work is breathable and flexible yet still offers great toe protection and protection from electrical hazards. In addition to all of this, it also offers you a slip-resistant outsole.

Breaking footwear can take a long time and lead to painful blisters and rubbed areas on your feet. The MemoryTech Footbed of the Subtle Cushion Work immediately starts conforming to your feet and their natural curves. This provides instant comfort to the wearer.

Due to the fact that Reebok builds running footwear, they understand how important flexibility is to overall comfort. Their Flex Groove outsole allows this choice to move with you and keep you at an optimal level of comfort. In addition, it will allow you to move easily and keep you on your feet.

Sources

  1. Staff, How do I clean safety boots, Blog
  2. safetyequipmentfaq, Steel toe boots and OSHA, Safety Information Site