Best Dr. Scholl’s Shoes Reviewed & Rated for Comfort
When you think about comforting insoles, we bet Dr. Scholl's is the first brand that comes to mind. What you may not have known is that they don’t just specialize in inserts but that they have their own line of footwear too. Wearing a pair is like finding the best pair of insoles without the hassle of having to fit them inside of your shoe.
With styles available for men, women, and children, there’s something for everyone. That’s exactly why we’ve carefully researched and reviewed the products available and created a detailed guide to ten of the absolute best. Continue reading for a closer look at the top ten pairs of Dr. Scholl's shoes, as well as, a more in-depth breakdown of the criteria used to evaluate each one.
In a Hurry? The test winner after 16 hrs of research
Memory Foam Insole
Hook & Loop Closure
10 Best Dr. Scholl's Shoes
Memory Foam Insole
Hook & Loop Closure
No Half Sizes
The Gaston is a casual sandal that features a leather upper unit and non-slip rubber outsole. This fisherman-style summer pair has contrast stitched-details and an adjustable strap with a secure hook-and-loop closure. The Gastons’ neoprene lining is soft against your skin while its memory foam insole provides the ultimate in comfort.Read more
The Gaston is a secure fitting sandal thanks to its heel strap that fastens with a hook-and-loop closure system. The most widely know fastening system of this style is Velcro, which offers an incredibly easy method that's completely customizable.
These Dr. Scholl's shoes have a memory foam insole that contours to the shape of your foot and retain an impression. This allows for a fit that's unique to you and is perfectly molded to hug every curve of your foot. The Gaston is very reasonably priced and offers excellent value. These sandals aren't your average pair of summer footwear; they're made to enhance every step. Best of all they offer a stylish design that mirrors much more expensive pairs.
Leather or Calf Hair Upper
Be Free Technology
Hillo Heel Cushion
Cru Stack Heel
You can never go wrong with a classic loafer, especially one that’s as good looking as the Faxon. Easy to dress up or down, this will easily become a staple in your wardrobe, and will get you from work to happy hour, to casual Sundays at the flower market. Being a flat, it is completely comfortable for long walks, plus, it comes in several beautiful color options.Read more
The cut of the Faxon combines style with comfort. The pointed toe elongates the line of the leg without creating excess pressure, and the instep allows for easy on and off that won’t cut into the foot, even if you have a higher instep than usual. At the back of the heel is a padded leather portion that keeps you cushioned and blister-free, so you can even choose to wear this model with no socks on.
The insole of this Dr. Scholl's shoe uses some of the brand’s best technology. The Be Free insole has three points of comfort, with high toe support, energy returning foam at the ball of the foot, and a cradling heel cup. The heel is covered with a rubber portion to increase shock absorption, but also to eliminate the possibility of slipping. In terms of cost association, this model ranks average, and it’s genuinely a great product to invest in for everyday wear.
Sustainable Leather Details
Limited Color Options
A knit sneaker made to bring your street style to the ultimate level, this model is a collaboration between this comfort oriented brand and the rapper whose name the sneaker carries. The model comes in two color options, one based on black, and the other on red, and is a great alternative to lifestyle sneakers that often don’t offer the required cushion and support for prolonged wear.Read more
The upper is crafted from an eco-friendly knit material that is highly breathable, extremely lightweight and that molds to the foot. Support is ensured through a heel strap made from sustainable leather. The interesting thing is that the knit materials, linings, and laces are all made from recycled plastic bottles, which make this one of the best sneakers of this kind.
The sole of the sneaker is made with plant-based cushioning that reduces waste, and does a great job at absorbing shock through your gait cycle. As for the outsole, it’s a gum rubber compound with an effective traction pattern and a unique print on the bottom. The price of this item is slightly higher than the average product by the brand, but on the whole, it’s worth the splurge.
Memory Foam Footbed
The Gordon is a simplistic leather sandal that’s made for comfort and ease of wear. Its slide-on style is perfect for those long summer days and makes transitioning from sand to city street a breeze. The Gordon boasts a full-grain leather upper and microsuede lining for an ideal next-to-skin feel.Read more
The Gordon is made from breathable full-grain leather that provides adequate airflow to the skin. Its flexible rubber outsole provides a solid grip on every surface including wet and slippery ones, while a microsuede lining keeps you walking with an enjoyable stride.
The Gordon was designed with a cushioned memory foam footbed that is so comfy you’ll want to wear them all the time. Its microsuede lining material is soft against bare skin and includes Aegis Microbe Shield technologies that work to prevent odors from occurring. This sandal is priced similarly to all the other pairs on this list and is an accessible pair for summertime living. These sandals deliver an ideal experience and are a solid investment in the overall health of your feet.
Narrow In The Toe
The Archie Fisherman is an enjoyable sandal that’s perfect for fun in the summer sun. Its lightweight design gives you the support your body craves while allowing for full range of motion. These sandals are perfect for any occasion and will have you feeling great no matter where your feet may end up taking you.Read more
The Archie’s stretch-fit detailing provides the perfect foundation for a customized fit. These sandals will stay firmly in place while maintaining a flexible feel thanks to the stretchy bungee cording that moves with you for an ideal experience.
The Archie Fisherman sandal features a super-comfy EVA midsole that delivers all-over enjoyment time after time. EVA is a manmade foam resin material that is notorious for its lightweight structure and fantastic cushioning. An EVA footbed is the definition of perfection when it comes to the platform on which you walk and will carry you for miles and miles without any aches or pains. The Archie is in-line with the other products on this list and is accessible for any budget. These sandals won’t fall apart halfway through the summer thanks to their sturdy design and quality craftsmanship which makes them a solid investment. The Archie is worth every cent and delivers a uniform level of protection and comfort, so go ahead and hit the trail in these sandals that were made for walking.
Oil & Slip-Resistant
Sole Prone To Split
The Harrington is a stylish oxford that’s ready to put in the hours at work. No matter your trade this pair has got all your needs covered! Their oil and slip-resistant Lock Step Outsole™ is in-line with the SATRA TM63 and TM144 standards so your safety is assured while you’re on the job. The Harrington boasts a leather upper and four-eyelet lacing system that keeps this pair firmly in place, while their lightweight SEBS midsole lets you move freely. Its non-marking outsole is perfect for wear on any flooring material so you won’t have to worry about scuffs or scrapes.Read more
Dri-Lex is a specialized lining material that wicks moisture away from the skin preventing a build-up of sweat and odors. Its built-in Aegis Microbe Shield works hard to protect you from unpleasant odors by naturally deodorizing the footbed.
Memory Foam Cool Fit is an advanced anti-compression technology. It’s built into the footbed creating a superior cushion that protects the delicate underside of the foot and provides adequate arch support. This is an ideal footbed for those suffering from plantar fasciitis. For a shoe that offers this many benefits, it’s hard to believe their low price-tag! The Harrington is a quality pair of footwear that’s constructed with your overall comfort and health in mind. They’re built tough to outlast the competition while providing a supportive environment that cradles your feet with every step.
Leather Wrapped Heel
2 ¼ Inch Wedge
Memory Foam Insole
Laces Come Undone
A wedge bootie, ideal for chilly weather, the Dakota is a stylish addition to anyone’s closet. This neutral model will look fantastic with your favorite pair of skinny jeans, or even a dress for dressier occasions. Being versatile enough to be worn for both casual occasions and professional wear, the Dakota truly is a good investment for those looking for a comfortable pair of fall footwear.Read more
The upper of this model is made with smooth faux suede that has numerous benefits. For one, it is really easy to break in, and will mold to the wearer’s foot to provide the best possible fit. Secondly, it is breathable, soft, and most importantly, non-irritating. The laces are waxed for easy handling and durability.
On the inside of this model, you’ll get a cooling effect memory foam insole that absorbs shock. Coupled with the 2 ¼ inch wedge heel, you will get a stable high heeled boot that doesn’t put excess pressure on the forefoot, and that is stable enough to be worn on an everyday basis. In terms of price, this is a model that can be purchased at an average cost, making it an overall good choice.
Less Stylish Than Others
The Brisk is a sneaker designed for walkers who spend long periods of time on their feet. Made with an air-pillow gel insole and lightweight structure, the Brisk lets you stride with ease. Their easy-to-use Velcro closures make for easy on and off wearability, while their mesh detailing keeps feet cool and dry all day long.Read more
The Brisk features dual straps which securely attach to Velcro closures. Velcro is a hook-and-loop style of fastening system that keeps your footwear securely in place while allowing the wearer total control over the fit. Velcro is extremely easy to operate and makes for no-fuss wear.
Mesh detailing at the sides keeps your feet cool and dry, while the Brisk's leather upper allows for adequate airflow around the foot. An air pillow gel insoles keep your feet moving in comfort thanks to the additional arch support and supple underfoot cushion that these sneakers offer. This is an inexpensive pair of walking sneakers that are made to keep your feet healthy and fit while feeling their best. No matter if you're walking for hours on end, or just around the shopping market and back, this pair has everything you could need and more.
Material Stretches With Wear
The Madison will fast become your go-to favorite for its sheer ease of wear. This slip-on pair is super-stylish so you won’t have any trouble matching them with your favorite outfit. The Madison is made with quality materials like microfiber, calf hair, and velvet, with your choice of upper unit fabric. They offer an exquisite lining that’s soft against the skin and a non-slip rubber outsole that keeps you steady on your feet.Read more
The Madison is anything but boring thanks to its wide array of colors and versatility in the choice of materials. Its color contrasted heel and statement white outsole add a pop of vibrancy, while their solid toned upper unit balances their look perfectly. You’ll love how easy it is to match these with any outfit including skirts, dresses, pants, and shorts.
The Madisons’ an easy-wearing pair of footwear! Their slip-on design makes for a no-fuss on and off experience, while their breathable and lightweight materials keep you feeling cool and fresh. No more delays or time wasted tying your shoelaces so you can get to where you’re going that much faster! The Madison is a fairly affordable pair of sneakers! They offer an incredibly comfy ride and no-fuss wearability that makes these a favorite among wearers. Their subtle style is easily matched with most outfits so you shouldn't have any trouble with clashing designs.
Can be Worn for Long Hours
Bottom Can Crack
This pair of wedge booties has everything you could need from a pair of footwear. They’re a cute and adaptable choice that will have you walking with ease thanks to their solid platform and thicker wedge heel. The Harlow was made with your health in mind and is designed to cradle your foot with every step. These booties will look great with a dress or any pair of jeans so go ahead and try them with your favorite outfit.Read more
The Harlow was designed for easy wearability and has concealed elastic goring to keep them firmly in place. Their synthetic outsole is slip-resistant for secure footing on any surface, even wet or slippery ones. You can feel at ease while wearing a pair of Harlow heels knowing that they look as good as they feel.
This pair of heels features a 3-inch wedge heel that’s a breeze to walk in and is available in two colors: black and taupe. The Harlows’ rounded toe downplays the size of your feet and gives the illusion of a smaller structure. This pair of boots is dainty yet functional and is a great choice for shopping or other casual outings. The Harlow is a reasonably priced pair of boots that are super-cute! They’re easy to match with almost any outfit and they soon become a wardrobe staple thanks to their ease of wear. This pair will keep your feet feeling comfy all day long thanks to their cushioned footbed and support structure.
Criteria Used for Evaluation
The brand’s footwear is made with every individual’s unique needs in mind. They offer options for men, women, and children, as well as, specialized pairs designed for wear while you’re on the job. Each category provides its own set of individualized features that make this line of footwear truly amazing. Let’s take a closer look at the differences;
The footwear that’s designed for work offers unique benefits and features that are made to support your feet during those long hours spent on the move. Continue below for a more detailed description of these shoes’ features:
Some additional benefits seen in their workwear are slip and oil-resistance, along with non-marking outsoles that won’t scuff up the flooring where you work.
The menswear line offers many of the same great benefits found with the pair for working only with some added street-style. There are several collections to choose from, including sport, casual, boots, and summer shoes. Each provides the same comfort-enhancing technologies mentioned above only without the additional safety-related features.
Options for women fall under four categories: sports, flats, casuals, and summer shoes. Each offers the same great features we’ve come to expect from this brand minus the added work-related ones. Women love this line for their stylish looks that feel ooh-soo-great and prevent those tired achy legs and feet at the end of the day.
Don’t think that your little ones have been excluded because there’s a line of footwear made especially for kids too. There are options for children ranging in age from toddlers to grade school and the styles are super trendy while offering the same great comfort as the adult pairs.
As we’ve mentioned, this brand’s footwear comes in many trendy looks and styles. In fact, these ultra-comfy pairs are often more in-style than some of the big names like Nike or Adidas. Let’s delve into the different options available;
The really great thing about this line of footwear is that they offer nice looking pairs that are super comfy. Normally we expect a shoe that’s designed to benefit the health of your feet will be unattractive, visually. That’s just not the case with these pairs! They look just as good as any other option out there.
The brand has created a patented Foot Mapping™ process that has changed the world of orthotic footwear. This unique system isolates the areas of your feet where you put the most strain and matches you with the level of orthotic insert most applicable to your needs. This system ensures that you’re getting the added support and stability that you need, right where you need it.
Orthotics are specially designed supports for the foot that assist with things like better arch support, balance, and correction of abnormalities. Orthotics come in the form of separate inserts which can be purchased, or in the form of footwear which includes orthotic insoles. This is a brand that’s infamous for making insole, both orthotic and traditional, that actually help people which is why they’re a household name. Their footwear is crafted with the same quality as their insert products only without the need to purchase a separate insert.
When we were evaluating different products from Dr. Scholl's, we wanted to ensure that, given their expertise in the field, each was comfortable and that the cushioning and foam that they used was the same quality and durable. To do this, we always consulted with previous reviews to see what customers were saying regarding their personal experiences.
While the brand uses different types of comfort-oriented features in each model, there are a few things you can expect from your new pair of Dr. Scholl's shoes. These include:
One of the most important criteria that we used to choose the best products was the price tag. We know that consumers care about how much a product cost. In truth, if you saw a pair of sandals that cost $200, you would have a lot of resistance – unless that product was within your budget.
With that being said, as we selected each product we carefully looked at the prices and costs to ensure that not only did it match the value of the product, but that it was not abnormally high or absurd, considering the market value. Do note though, typically all of this brand’s products are quite fairly priced, which this buying guide represents.
Expert Interviews & Opinions
William Scholls patented an arch design, which he then applied to making footwear that supports you. Since the patent, he's developed over 1000 foot aids!
The line of Dr. Scholl's footwear ranges from sandals, to flats, sneakers, and fashionable heels or wedges. And, with comfort in mind, you can rest assured you'll find one you love look wise, but that will help keep a spring in your step during longer days too.
Other Factors to Consider
Dr. Scholl's was founded back in 1906 by podiatrist William Mathias Scholl. Since then, its goal has remained the same, to make products that comfort your feet. The very first pair was created in an effort to produce a pair of footwear that was actually good for your overall health. These wooden shoes with a colorful strap were inspired by an old-school clog and eventually became an iconic piece of fashion history. Through the decades they’ve continually engineered unique options that were simplistic in design yet brilliant in their approach to a healthier lifestyle.
Now, we have a wide variety of styles to choose from. And while the look of the shoe is dependent on your style preference, one thing is for sure: any shoe you choose will have an amazingly comfortable insole that will keep your feet happy as long as you're wearing your shoes.
Frequently Asked Questions
q: Are these just a normal pair with an insert inside like what you buy from the drugstore?
No. While they do manufacture inserts which sell separately, the footwear they produce is much more than just a normal shoe with a pre-inserted insole. Their footwear is designed to conform to the contours of your foot and provide just the right level of cushion and support to the areas which need them the most. These pairs do not have inserts fitted inside but are made to provide the same, if not better, level of comfort.
q: Can I still wear them if I have wide feet?
Absolutely! This line of footwear is made with options that are suitable to every foot shape. Whether you have a wide or narrow structure there’s a pair that’s perfect for you. It’s best to read the product description to asses whether or not a pair will be wide enough.
q: Can I wear my separate insoles inside of these?
If you prefer to wear your own inserts there is no reason why you can’t. Just because this footwear is made to provide a similar level of comfort as a separate insole, doesn’t mean that you wouldn’t prefer the additional cushion and support. These options are made to fit a removable insole, though their’s are mostly fixed.
q: What makes these better than any other pair?
This is a brand that’s been in the shoemaking business since the early 1900’s. William Scholl, their founder, was a trained podiatrist who spent his life dedicated to the pursuit of enhancing people health, especially when it came to their feet. Each pair is ergonomically designed to enhance your health and better your overall performance. Whether it’s casual slip-on styles or athletic performance pairs you’re looking for, there’s something for everyone from this line.
q: Do they fit true to size?
This depends on the specific pair you’re interested in, but as a rule, they are fairly true to size. It’s always best to read the individual product description, along with reviews from real users, to assess if they’re going to be a good fit. User reviews are a great place to get a feel for the experiences real customers have had with an item. Just be sure to read reviews from “verified buyers” because then you know the person has actually tried the item that they’re reviewing. This gives you a better chance of reading honest reviews that will be helpful to you when it comes to deciding on the right pair to purchase.