to top 10 table

Best Frye Boots Reviewed & Rated

last updated Jul 05, 2019

People love boots, especially when they are durable, comfortable, and stylish. That’s where this shoemaking company comes in. John A. Frye opened the first company in Marlboro, MA in 1863; yet it wasn’t until 1888 that the brand’s first boot came out. It was made with fine quality leather and precise stitching, which came to be known as the brand’s trademarks. In 1923, they started using the Goodyear welt, and this construction method allows the foot to breathe but is also one of the sturdiest ones available.

In a Hurry? The test winner after 100 hrs of research

icon
Smith Engineer
97.8/100 our score
Materials
99
Upper
97
Outsole
98
Heel
96
Durability
99
Smith Engineer
Why is it better?
  • Sewn On Soles
  • Fairly True To Size
  • True To Color
In a Hurry? Editors choice:
Smith Engineer
Test Winner: Smith Engineer
Amazon Link
Researched Sources
15
Researched Sources
Reviews Considered
15,000
Reviews Considered
Hours Researching
100
Hours Researching
Products Evaluated
20
Products Evaluated
Sorting Options
Materials Upper Outsole Heel Durability By Default
Rank
PictureProduct
Name
Rating
Shops
#1
The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
97.8
Materials
99 %
Upper
97 %
Outsole
98 %
Heel
96 %
Durability
99 %
Price Comparison Last Updated (15.09.19)
Amazon Link
$318.00
#2
The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
95.4
Materials
95 %
Upper
97 %
Outsole
94 %
Heel
96 %
Durability
95 %
Price Comparison Last Updated (15.09.19)
Amazon Link
$207.00
#3
The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
93.8
Materials
94 %
Upper
95 %
Outsole
93 %
Heel
94 %
Durability
93 %
Price Comparison Last Updated (15.09.19)
Amazon Link
$145.99
#4
The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
91.6
Materials
92 %
Upper
93 %
Outsole
90 %
Heel
91 %
Durability
92 %
Price Comparison Last Updated (15.09.19)
Amazon Link
$119.99
#5
The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
90.2
Materials
90 %
Upper
91 %
Outsole
89 %
Heel
92 %
Durability
89 %
Price Comparison Last Updated (15.09.19)
Amazon Link
$388.00
#6
The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
86.6
Materials
87 %
Upper
85 %
Outsole
88 %
Heel
86 %
Durability
87 %
Price Comparison Last Updated (15.09.19)
Amazon Link
$297.50
#7
The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
84
Materials
86 %
Upper
85 %
Outsole
82 %
Heel
83 %
Durability
84 %
Price Comparison Last Updated (15.09.19)
Amazon Link
$298.00
#8
The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
81.6
Materials
82 %
Upper
80 %
Outsole
83 %
Heel
81 %
Durability
82 %
Price Comparison Last Updated (15.09.19)
Amazon Link
$279.95
#9
The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
77
Materials
78 %
Upper
76 %
Outsole
74 %
Heel
77 %
Durability
80 %
Price Comparison Last Updated (15.09.19)
Amazon Link
$277.95
#10
The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
76.4
Materials
79 %
Upper
76 %
Outsole
77 %
Heel
74 %
Durability
76 %
Price Comparison Last Updated (15.09.19)
Amazon Link
$154.99

10 Best Frye Boots

1. Smith Engineer

The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
97.8
Smith Engineer
Amazon Link
Materials
99
Upper
97
Outsole
98
Heel
96
Durability
99
best offer for today
Amazon Link
$318.00
Pros:
  • Sewn On Soles
  • Fairly True To Size
  • True To Color
Cons:
  • May Be Difficult To Pull On And Off

The Smith Engineer Boot is an ankle high boot made in the classic style of the horse riding boot. It’s made of leather, has tonal welt stitching, and has a low stacked heel. The high-quality leather boot has a high oil content, so watch for blooming, which can look like white powder. To get rid of blooming, all you have to do is wipe it off with a clean, damp cloth.

Read more

The midsole of the Smith Engineer is foam for your comfort and the insole is made of leather. Both are to keep your feet nice and cushioned during your walks.

The stacked heel is actually quite important if you’re going to use these boots for riding as this is where your boot will grip the stirrup. Can’t have you falling off your horse, now can we? The Smith Engineer can be one of the cheapest boots on this list or it can be one of the most expensive, depending on where you get it. Since this is an actual riding boot, make sure you’re buying authentic, whatever the case may be.

2. Parker Moc Short

The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
95.4
Parker Moc Short
Amazon Link
Materials
95
Upper
97
Outsole
94
Heel
96
Durability
95
best offer for today
Amazon Link
$207.00
Pros:

Comfortable To Walk In

Casual Style For Every Day Wear

Fit As Wxpected

Cons:

May Be Narrow

Who doesn’t love the look of a cute moccasin? That’s what inspired the Parker Moc Short Boot. They’re a great boot you can walk around in all day. They’re made of leather, with a chunky stacked heel, and slim leather laces to really make that look pop. The circumference is adjustable for the wearer.

Read more

The adjustable circumference of the Parker Moc Short makes it easier to get your foot in through the door, as it were. No matter the unique shape and size of your foot, you can find a snug and secure fit in the Parker Moc Short.

The Parker Moc comes in multiple colors to match with all of your outfits. Because this boot is more on the casual side, you’ll want to wear it with everything you own. With a range of colors spanning the spectrum, the Parker Moc is a versatile option for someone looking for a stylish boot.

3. Carson Wedge

The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
93.8
Carson Wedge
Amazon Link
Materials
94
Upper
95
Outsole
93
Heel
94
Durability
93
best offer for today
Amazon Link
$145.99
Pros:
  • Not As Heavy As Some Others
  • Comfortable To Walk In
  • Fits True To Size
Cons:
  • May Be Narrow

The Carson Wedge Bootie is a more sophisticated boot than the Parker Moc Short. It will go well with everyday wear as well as professional wear. It has a leather upper as well as a beautiful hand done finish. The lining on the inside is smooth leather. The bootie also includes a leather footbed for extra comfort.

Read more

The Carson Wedge has a back zip closure for easy on and off. This eliminates any hassle with shoelaces and makes putting on your boots completely uncomplicated.

If you’ve ever read an article on shoes, you know how important keeping your feet comfortable is. Having a leather footbed in your Carson Wedge Booties is nice because it gives you that extra padding that you may not get in other boots.

4. Wyatt Harness

The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
91.6
Wyatt Harness
Amazon Link
Materials
92
Upper
93
Outsole
90
Heel
91
Durability
92
best offer for today
Amazon Link
$119.99
Pros:
  • Easy Break In
  • Good Arch Support
  • Room In Toe Box
Cons:
  • May Not Work Well With High Arches

The Wyatt Harness Short Boot is unlike any of the other boots on this list. It has an interesting and upper design. It’s made of leather that is durable and comfortable. The upper is made of antique soft, vintage leather. The interior is lined with leather. And the outsole is leather with a rubber forepart.

Read more

The Wyatt Harness Short Boot is made to fit many women. It is made of leather covered elastic gore with stretch, which gives it its scrunched up look. It also fits more easily.

The leather lined interior will give your foot a nice, natural nesting place. It will also make the boot easier to slip on and off. The Wyatt Harness Short Boot can either be one of the mid prices on this list or it can be the most expensive boot on here, depending. However, due to its unique style, it may be worth spending an extra few dollars on it.

5. Harness 12R

The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
90.2
Harness 12R
Amazon Link
Materials
90
Upper
91
Outsole
89
Heel
92
Durability
89
best offer for today
Amazon Link
$388.00
Pros:
  • Wide Fit
  • Made In The USA
  • Wide Toe Box
Cons:
  • May Have To Go Down Half A Size

The Harness 12R Boot is similar in style to the Harness 8R, except that it is longer. The shaft measure about 12” from the arch on the 12R, whereas it’s 7.5” on the 8R. The Harness 12R has a square toe box and a harness strap. The sides have easy, pull-on handles. Like the 8R it has a studded leather strap on the ankle for that rugged look.

Read more

The square toe box of the Harness 12R may make it easier for some people to fit their toes in the toe box. A lot of the previous boots came narrowly in the toes and this may make it easier for people to get their shape right.

Getting a mid-calf boot on can get pretty difficult unless you have something to hang onto. In come the easy-on pulls of the Harness 12R. They make it easy to pull your boot right on.

6. Jackie Gore

The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
86.6
Jackie Gore
Amazon Link
Materials
87
Upper
85
Outsole
88
Heel
86
Durability
87
best offer for today
Amazon Link
$297.50
Pros:
  • Easy On/Off
  • No Break In
  • Fits Pretty True To Size
Cons:
  • May Be Narrow In The Toe Box

Another different, but beautiful boot on the list is the Jackie Gore Stitching Boot. This one is reminiscent of days long past, completely classic. There is dual goring underneath decorative, die-cut leather mid boot. The trim takes up much of the boot and is the centerpiece of it. The boot is 100% leather with a debossed logo at the heel.

Read more

The Jackie Gore has to get on your foot somehow, right? That’s what the pull-on loop strap is for. And you thought it was just for decoration because it’s so pretty with all those studs and stitching.

A leather sole can be a really great thing to have in a boot as it conforms to your foot, leading the way with comfort. The leather also gives a touch of elegance and class to the boot, which is already so beautiful.

7. Harness 8R

The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
84
Harness 8R
Amazon Link
Materials
86
Upper
85
Outsole
82
Heel
83
Durability
84
best offer for today
Amazon Link
$298.00
Pros:
  • Made In The USA
  • Substantial Arch In Boot
  • Classic Style
Cons:
  • Heavier Than Some Others
  • May Need A Half Size Down

The Harness 8R Boot is a rugged boot to get the job done. It's outlined with features like the memory foam insoles, durable materials, and construction including Goodyear Welting, and lifted heel. This boot has all of the work and play in it with the studded leather strap at the ankle.

Read more

The Harness 8R has cushioned shock-absorbing memory insoles, making each step on the ground a little easier and lighter on your body. This will work to save the joints in your body a lot of stress.

The Harness 8R has an oil resistant sole, which means that the sole is specially designed to keep from easily slipping on oil. This is particularly great if you use this boot for work around oil, such as a mechanic’s shop.

8. Veronica Short

The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
81.6
Veronica Short
Amazon Link
Materials
82
Upper
80
Outsole
83
Heel
81
Durability
82
best offer for today
Amazon Link
$279.95
Pros:
  • Moderate Arch Support
  • Subtle But Firm Cushioning
  • Easy Break In
Cons:
  • May Need A Half Size Smaller

The Veronica Short Boot is a classic engineer boot with antiqued logo buckles. It has two buckles, one at the opening, one at the ankle. The boot is made of 100% leather with leather and rubber sole, featuring a stacked leather 1-inch heel. The Veronica Short also comes with a cushioned foam insole.

Read more

The cushioned foam insole is meant to hold your foot comfortably inside. It helps relieve the shock to your feet when walking as well.

Both of the buckles on the Veronica Short are adjustable to fit your foot. You can move them to the exact right measurement they need to be on to fit your exact comfort level.

9. Jenna

The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
77
Jenna
Amazon Link
Materials
78
Upper
76
Outsole
74
Heel
77
Durability
80
best offer for today
Amazon Link
$277.95
Pros:
  • Rounded Toe
  • Wider Opening For Wider Calves
  • Not As Heavy As Some Others
Cons:
  • May Be Difficult To Put On And Take Off

The Jenna Engineer Boot is another engineer boot on this list but more distressed than the Veronica Short. Other than that, the two are very similar. There are two adjustable buckles and the shaft is only half an inch shorter than the one of the Veronica Short. The shaft circumference and heel heights are the same.

Read more

Like the buckles on the Veronica Short, the buckles on the Jenna Engineer are adjustable for maximum comfort. They let you decide on how loose or tight the fit needs to be in order for you to feel most at ease in your boots.

Now you don’t have to worry about scuffing up your boots; they come that way! The distressed look of your boots will make it easier to put dings and scratches on them without the guilt.

10. Phillip Harness Tall

The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
76.4
Phillip Harness Tall
Amazon Link
Materials
79
Upper
76
Outsole
77
Heel
74
Durability
76
best offer for today
Amazon Link
$154.99
Pros:
  • Leather On The Inside
  • Pretty True To Size
  • Easy Break-In
Cons:
  • May Have Trouble With Zipper

The Phillip Harness Tall Boot measures 17” from the arch. It’s the tallest one on the list, made of leather and hand-burnished and distressed. The gorgeous part of this boot is the leather’s uneven coloring. Due to the concentration of oil in different areas, the boot reflects highs and lows.

Read more

For a look that you can’t destroy, because it’s supposed to look that way, the Phillip Harness Tall Boot is your ticket. You can restore it to its original beauty with cleaning or polishing oils, knowing it will maintain that stylish distressed look over its entire product life.

This extremely tall boot gets on and off with a back zip, so you don’t have to worry about struggling to get it on and off. The zipper is of high-quality and doesn't snag when trying to zip up or down. It earns high marks in the durability department!

Criteria Used for Evaluation

Materials

You should always know what type of material your boot is made of. This will let you know how long it will hold and how to take care of it. All the boots on this list are made of leather. Generally, real leather is stronger than synthetic leather, making it more durable. The most durable natural leathers are full grain and top grain. Suede is also real leather, but it is softer and needs more care than the other two.

With real leather, you want to take care of your boots. Clean them regularly, condition, and oil them. This treatment will prevent the leather from cracking and deteriorating and extend the life of your boots.

You will also want to consider other factors related to the material construction of your boot. Will it stand up to rain and water? Are you living in a cold or warm climate? Do you need a boot that breathes because you have a unique foot condition or are sensitive to moisture? Consider all of these factors when deciding on your perfect pair of boots!

Upper

Insoles are another thing to consider when buying boots. The insole is the part of the shoe that supports your foot on the inside. Insoles provide cushioning as well. They can be made of foam, which is common. Foam naturally absorbs shock and is dependable and rigid. Memory foam insoles mold to the foot, retaining the shape, which makes them particularly comfortable.

The issue with foam is that it doesn’t have a long lifespan. Leather is another insole cushion. Leather is tough and long lasting and it can provide strong arch support. Finally, gel can be an insole cushion. It’s flexible and soft. The Veronica Short has a foam insole that will leave your foot feeling comfortable. The Paige Tall Riding Boot has an insole made of leather, which will last a long time.

Also remember that while a softer insole might be more comfortable, but that comes at the expense of stability and durability. We tried to balance these weights when evaluating our products, but each reader and wearer is different, so be aware of this trade-off.

Outsole

The type of sole you have depends a lot on the style of shoe you choose. There are pros and cons to rubber and leather alike. For instance, although leather is more elegant, and if done properly, more durable, it may not be quite as comfortable as the softer rubber is to walk on. When walking on pavement, especially if you’re used to a softer rubber sole, walking on a leather sole may be hard at first.

However, if done correctly, a leather sole can be quite soft. It also offers elegance which the rubber sole just does not. A properly made leather sole also will be waterproof. The Jackie Gore Stitching Boot has a leather sole for that classic look that you want at formal events.

Depending on the type of footwear, one will often see outsoles made from natural or synthetic materials, such as PVC, EVA, rubber, and leather. Each of these has their advantages, depending on the shoe’s purpose; however, as a general rule, they each are resistant to the aforementioned factors. They are also flexible enough to support a proper foot cycle when in motion, but they are not so flexible that they feel like a pair of socks.

Heel

The heel height of a boot is extremely important. You want to be sure you’re picking a boot with a heel height that’s comfortable for you. If you’re the type of person that is comfortable in 3” then, by all means, get that Parker Moc Short Boot that you’re eyeing.

On the other hand, if you tend to spend most of your time low to the ground, then don’t struggle to walk on a heel that isn’t going to be comfortable for you, no matter how cute the boot is. There are plenty of choices on this list with heels that are 1” or shorter. And they’re super cute to boot.

Don't forget to remember that the higher the heel, the more pressure is placed on certain muscles in your ankle when you walk. A higher heel means more discomfort, so be aware of this trade-off if you are going to wear your boots for extended periods of time!

Durability

To assess each of the products on our list for durability, we not only read through thousands of customer reviews on our recommended products, but we also looked for some of the hallmarks of quality construction. From brand name reputation to their initial smell out of the box, there are a few ways of identifying a well-built, made-to-last product.

The Details
A zipper that doesn’t zip? Poor threading technique? A smelly, chemical residue on the shoe when you open the box? All these details were looked for an evaluated when assigning a score for durability.

Materials
Certain materials last longer than others, even if that comes at the expense of a higher score in the “comfort” criterion. Materials that are synthetic, thicker, and firmer tend to score higher on durability.

Product Purpose
A shoe made for running and high-impact sports will not likely last as long as a good pair of general activity shoes, and that’s okay. Being aware of the shoe’s purpose is critical for you as a reader and for us as a reviewer. Although shoes that will last longer score higher on this criterion, you might also see high scores to shoes with a more limited durability, if that product was specifically designed for certain purposes that involve high-impact and high-stress motions. We take into account the type of shoes you are trying to purchase when assigning scores to shoes in this criterion.

Expert Interviews & Opinions

Most Important Criteria (According to our experts opinion)
Sort criterias acording to:
Experts Opinion Editors Opinion Users Opinion By Default
Click on a to rate the most important criteria:
#1
ico Materials
Rate This Criteria as Most Important
#2
ico Upper
Rate This Criteria as Most Important
#3
ico Outsole
Rate This Criteria as Most Important
#4
ico Heel
Rate This Criteria as Most Important
#5
ico Durability
Rate This Criteria as Most Important
expert tips icon
Leather Care Tips

For any kind of leather shoe or boot, taking time to care for the material can greatly extend it's lifespan, and keep them looking great.
Use of leather conditioner on harder leathers will help keep them soft and supple, while leathers like suede can benefit from a shoe protectant spray to prevent water or other liquid stains.

Styling Your Frye Boots

Boots are one of the most versatile styles of footwear for cooler months, with leather helping to insulate and keep your feet warm.
Pair knee high boots with leggings or skinny jeans, dresses or skirts as well. Adding a fun sock to peek out at the top can add some flair and fun to your outfit as well.
For ankle boots, these again, can be paired with just about any kind of apparel. With more structured skirts and dresses, it adds to the element giving structure to your feet. Pair embellished ankle boots that have studs or fringe for something a bit more edgy and fun.

Other Factors to Consider

Bottom Line

By the 1940s, Frye was making cowboy boots. Some were worn by US General Patton during World War II. Half Wellingtons, or “Jet Boots,” came along in the 1950s and were worn by the navy and army long after the war. In the 1960s the brand custom-made boots for people such as Jackie Kennedy and President Nixon. The harness boot also came along in the 1960s. The 1970s brought about the campus boot and the 1990s the engineer boot.

Now that you know what the top ten are, you can think about all of the qualities that you want in your next boot. Of course, you want the boot to be stylish, comfortable, and durable. But the brand already has you covered on all of those things. Thing deeper. There is a range of styles represented on this list from riding boots, to engineer boots, to booties, to harness boots. You have to decide which style is the one for you. You have to decide if you like long boots or short boots.

What flatters your calves the most? You have to determine if you prefer to slip your boots on or if you need zippers or shoelaces. On the one hand, slipping your boots on and off can be quite convenient. On the other, some boots are harder to slip on and off than others. But then you have to decide if zippers or laces are more your style. Then there’s arch support to consider. How much of it do you need? Will the boots you like provide that or do you need to buy inserts? You have to consider how tall you want your heel to be. Once everything is in order, you can go ahead and pick your boots.

Frequently Asked Questions

q: Is heel slippage normal?

a:

With new boots, a small amount, yes. It will slowly decrease as you continue to wear them.

q: My foot is between sizes, what do I do?

a:

Order a half a size up. You can also put an insert in the the half size up is just a little too big. Alternatively, you can wear thicker socks that will give your more cushioning and fill up excess space.

q: How do I know I got authentic boots?

a:

Always order from the company directly, a reputable store, or a reputable website. First, check the packaging that it is a white box with the brand on it and the words “Benchcrafted since 1863.” Check the quality of the boot. If it is not up to standard (finest leather, stitching, and hardware), send it back. A true boot by this brand will also have FRYE stamped on the outsoles. Some use a Neoprene Safetech Oil Resistant stamp. Always know the styles and ensure all of the details are up to par.

q: Why pick this brand?

a:

Their boots are made with quality leather and stitching to last. They’ve been a proud label since their inception and have been making the finest boots ever since. Their products are designed to be stylish, comfortable out of the box, and durable for years to come.

q: Does the brand do any volunteer work?

a:

They have a partnership with Feeding America and have donated over 2 million meals through its many programs.