Best Shoe Polishes Reviewed & Rated
Criteria Used for Evaluation
But what is the difference between polish types, and what does each do? There are a few main features to consider, which defines the texture and main ingredients.
Shoe Wax – the consistency of the polish you select may have a little to 100% wax as one of the ingredients. Wax is what helps to protect the leather, and given its hydrophobic properties, helps give the shoe a water-resistant property.
Shoe Conditioner – A good leather conditioner is something that is readily absorbed into the leather to help keep it supple and prevent cracking and signs of wear over time.
Shoe Cream – Shoe creams help to add moisture to the leather, but unlike a conditioner, this layer of treatment remains on top of the shoe instead of being absorbed.
When searching for any type of shoe polish the first thing you should consider when picking your brand is the type of leather your specific shoe has and choosing your treatment accordingly. To make sure everyone is accommodated when purchasing, we included brands that work on all types of leather as well as more specific options such as synthetic or smooth leather.
The options we chose for all types of leather also operate as a multi-purpose glower as well, working on a variety of surfaces and product. These options are specifically tailored to those that aren’t very experienced in the world of footwear care and work perfectly as a budget everyday shine option to keep your footwear healthy and looking great.
On the other hand, one of the most popular types of leather used on the vast majority of shoes on the market is smooth leather. Brands such as Saphir are great options for this type of shoe as they provide great nourishment in extending the longevity of your shoes.
The components that make up a particular shoe polish are one of the main deciding points used to choose what brands to include on our list. Features such as the type of finish, smell, and cleaning ability are all considered and fall under this category.
The finish or glow left by a specific polish may more or less be a main buying point for the customer. Anything from glossy finishes to mirror finishes, are included in this list to tailor your needs to exactly what you’re looking for, but we also covered polishes that cover scuffs or condition and protect your leather shoe.
The smell of polish usually goes hand in hand with the quality of a specific mixture. This may not be a big deal for some, but a pungent type smell should definitely be avoided, and we’ve of course made sure to do so in this list as well.
Last but not least, is the most important feature a shoe polish should have and that’s of course ability to achieve the desired results. Every product featured on this list is a top of the line shoe product, each with their own strengths, perfect for covering up scratches, and in some cases, will work equally as well as a multi-cleaner.
Shoe polish ingredients can also become technical, based on the level of glow, protection, conditioning, or pigmentation you may need.
Ease of Use
Another key factor that we took into consideration when evaluating our items is their ease of application. Cleaning and conditioning footwear can be a long and arduous process if the products you are using have a complicated method of application, if you are not clear what type of brushes or cloths you are supposed to use, or - worst of all - if they tend to spill and run all over your hands and the floor, causing a mess.
Some options in this guide make your life easier by coming with an applicator of their own, which help you apply the product quickly and efficiently and spare your fingers from greasy stains. Those which do not usually come with a set of clear instructions on how to best apply them for maximum effect and minimum damage to your surroundings.
Before starting the process, make sure you've got a clean, protected working surface, as well as all the tools you will need, including polishing products, brushes, cloths, etc. It is also a good idea to keep your footwear on a shoe tree, ideally made out of cedar wood that will help it preserve its shape, and will speed up drying and deter mildew.
A great benefit of polishing your footwear - and again, one of the main reasons it should be done on a regular basis - is that this process keeps the leather soft, supple, and shiny. That’s right - it isn’t only about the rugged aspects, about protecting your footwear from the tough outdoors, but it is also for keeping your it as good as new, for restoring its original glow and for making it comfortable again.
That is not to say that all hope is lost for footwear which has lost its shine, is dull and cracking, grown stiff over the years. If your first thoughts were to throw it away - don’t! There is still hope for these poor neglected things, even if they haven’t been cared for in a long, long time. Thoroughly cleaning and conditioning with proper products can breathe new life into your shoes, and you will find yourself with a near-mint pair of shoes which you can continue wearing for even longer.
To ensure the best possible results, it is crucial that you choose the right type of care for your footwear. That is to say, different types of leather will require different treatment, and the wrong type may actually do more damage than good. Another thing you should keep in mind is that polishing your favorite pair of footwear is the last step in the process of making it presentable - a thorough cleaning and conditioning should always be performed first, to ensure the leather not only looks good, but is healthy as well.
10 Best Shoe Polishes
1. Huberd's Original Shoe Grease
Founded in 1921 in Oregon, USA, this product was originally created to help protect logger’s boots against the elements, but also to help the leather last the rough and tough Great Northwest winters. Since then, they’ve expanded their product line for a variety of leather goods, but still keep the classic leather shoe protectant they were known and loved for, Huberd’s Original Shoe Grease.
Beeswax based, this product includes several conditioning oils sure to keep your shoes supple for the long haul. Beeswax provides a weather resistant quality to help keep out water and liquids, while the conditioning oils help soothe cracked leather and maintain flexibility. Several other products from Huberd's now combined this classic version with other oils for even more protection against the elements that worksites may encounter on a daily basis.
With a product such as Huberd’s, that’s been on the market since the 1920s, you can be sure there is a reason for its heritage and the quality of the product. Since the Original Shoe Grease was made with loggers in mind, it’s a good bet those hard workers encountered downpours, muddy conditions, and an environment that abused the leather boots that kept their feet safe. You can feel comfortable knowing that your shoes get the protection a work boot requires to keep your leather shoes safe! Protection like this doesn’t have to come at a premium with Huberd’s. Coming at a similar price for our top picks on our list, but in a 7.5-ounce container, you get double the product to help protect your shoes. If the color pigment is something you don’t require, but sturdy protection and conditioning are, Huberd’s Original Shoe Grease is for you.
2. Saphir Medaille D’or
Imported from Paris, France, Saphir Médaille d'Or Pâte de Luxe is a top of the line show polish considered to be the best in the world based purely off its combination of 10 different high-quality wax types. In addition, this shoe polish boasts a great all natural smell as well as comes in 8 different colors to match your leather perfectly, truly a premium product.
The Pate de Luxe Saphir Medaille d'Or comes in an easy to use wax that proves great coverage, perfect for using on any leather shoe. It is composed of multiple different waxes, including Beeswax and carnauba wax, each with their own specific technical properties. Combine this with a natural turpentine oil, and it’s clear how this has become a well-loved product.
The complex formula incorporated into this particular brand provides a sleek and glossy finish while the pigments utilized in the color options bring fantastic penetration as well as transparency to create a quality and exquisite shine. It’s part of the reason it’s a gold medal product, as the French name suggests. While the price may be a bit more on the expensive side, mainly as a result that the product is imported, the quality definitely speaks for itself. You’ll discover it’s supreme effects after you apply your very first coat to your shoes. If you’re looking for a top of the line product to really spice up your clothing regardless of price, then this is what you should shoot for.
3. Red Wing Mink Oil
The benefits of mink oil were first discovered by fur trappers who found that the natural substance greatly helped waterproof their footwear, in addition to conditioning it and making it soft and supple, thus comfortable for wear. The version by Red Wing was developed specially for their Heritage line which comprises of boots that can last a lifetime with the right care, and regular application of this product is definitely a step in that direction.
The benefits of mink oil over other types of similar products is that it does not promote the deterioration of finished and unfinished leather products, and can help prevent damage from water, salt, mildew and even mold. This mixture combines the natural ingredient with lanolin and silicone so that you can enjoy a high level of water resistance, while your footwear remains shiny, developing a unique patina with wear.
Made in the USA, this product comes in a 3 oz package, and can be used on all of your full-grain and smooth finished footwear and leather products. On application, it may darken your leather goods, so it is advisable to try it out on a small area first, to ensure you’ll be satisfied with the look you’ll get. It will lighten with wear. The price is average compared to other products listed, making it a good purchase for most.
4. Dr. Martens Wonder Balsam
With all the leather shoes and boots that Dr. Marten’s is known for as a brand, they’ve also made sure to create a product to keep those shoes looking fabulous. Dr. Marten’s Wonder Balsam is a mix of several components to help your shoes maintain suppleness and keep them protected from the elements. The best part of this treatment? No polishing is required!!! Simply wipe this top notch product onto the shoes, and wipe off.
Many products out there are color tinted and do require that you buff them to give a shine. Wonder Balsam helps the integrity of your leather shoes for long-term durability and life and requires no buffing. Simple wipe on the Balsam, leave for 5 minutes and wipe any excess off the shoe. You’ll notice an immediate difference in sheen, though this won’t have that ‘mirror’ finish most other products have.
Wonder Balsam is made with beeswax, coconut oil, and lanolin, perfect to help break in stiffer leather shoes. This kind of treatment helps to protect the shoe against salt marks, scuffing, and any water or liquid your boots or shoes may find themselves stepping in. It has a nice light smell to it and comes with an application sponge. A bit more expensive than other treatments, this 2.5 ounce supply is still worth every cent spent. With its easy application and striking results, Dr. Marten’s really has created a quality product. If you’re looking for a product that nourishes the leather of your shoes and extends the lifespan of the shoe considerably with regular treatment, this product should find its way into your home!
5. Otter Wax Leather Salve
Otter Wax Leather Salve is similar to a combined polish and leather moisturizer all in one. Consisting of natural shea butter plus a carnauba wax as the main ingredients, it helps to keep luster and pliability to the leather quality of your shoes or boots. With a little more arm work to polish up your shoes to a glow, this Leather Salve is sure to keep your shoes, and other leather products, looking young long into the turn of the century.
Otter Wax has a proprietary blend of butters, oils, and waxes blended into their Leather Salve, the two main components being carnauba wax and shea butter. It’s intended use is as a deep conditioner for leather, helping to restore luster, and keep the material supple and soft. If your shoes are looking a little dried out and cracked, simply apply a treatment and revel in the results!
The Leather Salve does require a bit more time if compared to Dr. Marten’s Wonder Balsam, which ensures proper uptake of the moisturizing products, and extra polish to help buffer up a shine. Within 10-20 minutes, most of the product will be absorbed by the leather, and an extra 5-10 minutes is needed wipe off the cloudy excess and buff in a shine to your leather shoes. Buffing is important here, as it helps to create a sealant as well as shine on the boot or shoe. Similar to our number one on the list, this 2 ounce. container of Otter Wax Leather Salve will give a deep conditioning treatment to your leather boots or shoes. The buffing will help seal and shine leather made products, and help extend their life even if they happen to be your favorite pair you wear every day. The protection you purchase with this product is a solid and smart investment.
6. Fiebing's Yellow Saddle Soap
Not only does the Fiebing’s Yellow Saddle Soap work great as a shoe polish but it also doubles an all-purpose leather cleaner including use on saddles as noted in the product title. Fiebing’s formula has been tried and true and has been used since 1895 throughout the United States proves to be one of the best all-purpose leather cleaners on the market.
Extending its reach to other countries around the world for use on fine saddlery, tack, and other articles of smooth leather including shoes, Fiebings Saddle Soap is one of the best shoe care products you can get your hands on. Made of a mixture of simple beeswax and soap Fiebings makes sure to prevent brittleness and maintains its strength after use on a variety of leather accessories.
Most companies can’t vouch for the versatility of their products but Fiebings sure can! Not only is this treatment great for leather boots and other footwear, but it also works fantastic on leather car seats, baseball gloves, belts, furniture, and of course, saddles. Its versatility on other leather products makes this brand one of the unique and useful products in the industry. You can never go wrong with Fiebing’s saddle soap. It brings a mix of versatility, and high-quality ingredients which make for a fantastic all-around U.S. made product. It’s versatile enough that you can rely on it for not only shoes but many other leather accessories at quite a low price considering its size.
7. Kiwi Shoe Polish
One of the giants in this industry and a must for military footwear as its formula quickly permeates and seeps into the leather to remove any scuffs and scratches, a go-to mirror shining product suitable for all leather goods and accessories.
Kiwi features a creamy substance composed of a simple but highly effective blend of many waxes including their highly perfected carnauba wax ensuring to keep your footwear looking great and free of any noticeable damage. This kind of product is sure to give an extra shine to your leather when buffed to perfection.
Although this brand does not provide that extravagant glossy look like the Saphir Medaille d'Or may, it excels in the concurrent usage of cleaning up any scratches. The Kiwi Shoe Polish Paste comes in an 8-ounce container, and with its relatively cheap price, makes this another great budget option. With a subtle shine and also acting as a great shoe cleaner, it's clear why this is the go-to option for not only the Military but everyday shoe and leather enthusiasts as well.
8. Saphir Crème Surfine
Saphir has been making quality polish and crème products on the market for quite some time, and with their base established in France, you can be certain this company knows what leather needs. Two of their products fall in our top ten list, the first being their Crème Surfine, a pigmented crème great for all-purpose leather product treatment.
Combining beeswax base with conditioning oils and pigment, Saphirs Crème Surfine will help keep your shoes from brandishing discolored scuff marks, while helping to keep them protected from the elements. This crème smooths tired looking leather in supple conditioning, leaving your shoes with the original grace and charm characteristics they were created with.
Slightly newer of a product than the classic Saphir Medaille d'Or, these cremes come in over 70 colors you can choose from. Use black for your black, or even dark brown shoes, but with the number of colored leathers shoe area available in these days, you’ll be able to find one best to match your particular shoe color. Apply this regularly to help maintain luster and color, and it’s best when used in combination with proper wax polish, such as the Pate de Luxe sold by Saphir. The Crème Surfine is sold in a 50mL container, slightly less volume than some of their other products, but also slightly cheaper. If you have colored leather, you’re looking to correct scuff marks, and give a deep conditioning treatment to, this product is a good one to select. Make sure to use a polish afterward for additional luxe shine!
9. Cherry Blossom Cream
The Cherry Blossom Renovating Shoe Cream is yet another great shoe polish fantastic for all types of leathers. It also is supplied in a larger size perfect for buying in quantity. Cherry Blossom has been a staple in the shoe polish industry for quite some time, providing customers with a fantastic glow. With its composition of all natural materials, it’s a great option to clean up your shoe game.
Cherry Blossom implements a blend of multiple different waxes consisting of 100% all natural ingredients for a great smell as a well as fantastic quality for all types of leather. This makes it a reliable and cheap option, especially considering the size they are available in to buy. Wax based treatments help to protect shoes from the messy wet weather, and with the more wax, the better protection you may have.
To further break down what exactly makes this product so good is the ingredients utilized to get that perfect shine. This all natural product contains a blend of naphtha, lanolin, turpentine, wax (often Carnauba wax), Arabic gum, ethylene glycol, and often a colorant of some sort. Combined, it creates a fantastic high quality, all in one blend, and suitable for all types of leather shoes and accessories. The cost is great for the size of tin you get, and for the quality of ingredients. You can never go wrong with Cherry Blossom products, and this shoe polish is no exception. Cherry Blossom Cream is truly a fantastic protective product and something everyone should have in their clothing arsenal.
10. TRG The One Shoe Cream
Imported from Europe, TRG "The One" Shoe Cream is a wonderful polish that nourishes and cares for your leather products with a rich and quick drying solution. In addition, it is available in over 50 colors to choose from, again perfect for those looking to touch up scuffs and scrapes!
TRG shoe cream is composed of pigmented natural waxes that cleans up any scuffs and adds shine to make your shoes look great again. Also, TRG cream has a great smell due to its use of unique ingredients and can bind quite nicely to smooth leather products as well.
Coming in several color hues and options on the top ten list, TRG Shoe Cream provides a multitude of high quality and choices. Select your preference to best help tailor your shine exactly to the color of your leather, refreshing your shoes look and protection as well as style. Great for synthetic leathers as well! TRG The One Shoe Cream is shipped directly from Europe to the US, as it’s not available in the US so that shipping may bump up the overall price of the product. It’s more expensive on our top ten list when we compare its 1.5-ounce container to a price similar to our top picks. However, this shoe cream is still a great show polish with a plethora of color options, perfect for leather enthusiasts.
- Choosing Polish Color, ,
- The Difference Between Shoe Conditioner, Cream, and Wax, ,
- Wax Vs. Cream Polish, ,
- Polish Your Shoes Properly, ,
- Shine Your Shoes Like A Soldier, ,
- HOW TO - MATCHING SHOE CREAM, ,
- The Best Products for Maintaining and Shining Leather Shoes, ,
- Dr. Martens Care Kit, ,
- Otter Wax Leather Salve, ,
- Saphir Products, ,