to top 10 table

Best Shoes For Prom & Formal Reviewed & Rated

last updated May 24, 2019

Prom night is a significant part of your adolescent years and for many, is an essential turning point in your lives. For a night as unforgettable as prom, everyone wants to look their absolute best; months are spent preparing every detail making sure it’s all going to come together flawlessly. One of the most prominent parts of an outfit is the shoes, the right pair can bring a disaster of a look together, while the wrong ones can spoil the hottest look faster than an egg left out in the sun. But it can be super-tough to find the right pair of shoes that will accentuate your gorgeous outfit and cap-off your award-worthy style, which is why we’ve written this list.

In a Hurry? The test winner after 18 hrs of research

icon
Katy Perry The Stella
95.8/100 our score
Style
97
Comfort
98
Fit
95
Brand
94
Value
95
Katy Perry The Stella
Why is it better?

Star Design

Slip-On

Two Color Options

3.5" Heel

In a Hurry? Editors choice:
Katy Perry The Stella
Test Winner: Katy Perry The Stella
Amazon Link
Researched Sources
15
Researched Sources
Reviews Considered
1278
Reviews Considered
Hours Researching
18
Hours Researching
Products Evaluated
20
Products Evaluated
Last Updated:
Mackenzie Jervis
By Mackenzie Jervis:

The recent update reflects the best of 2019’s shoes for prom of all types, shapes, sizes, colors, with new information as to how to choose the best prom footwear and our criteria for evaluation. Also, included are some of the most frequently asked questions about prom shoes.

Sorting Options
Style Comfort Fit Brand Value By Default
Rank
PictureProduct
Name
Rating
Shops
#1
The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
95.8
Style
97 %
Comfort
98 %
Fit
95 %
Brand
94 %
Value
95 %
Price Comparison Last Updated (16.09.19)
Amazon Link
$38.95
#2
The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
92.2
Style
91 %
Comfort
92 %
Fit
94 %
Brand
90 %
Value
94 %
Price Comparison Last Updated (16.09.19)
Amazon Link
$59.99
#3
The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
91.2
Style
93 %
Comfort
90 %
Fit
91 %
Brand
92 %
Value
90 %
Price Comparison Last Updated (16.09.19)
Amazon Link
$31.99
#4
The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
89.6
Style
90 %
Comfort
88 %
Fit
89 %
Brand
90 %
Value
91 %
Price Comparison Last Updated (16.09.19)
Amazon Link
$31.99
#5
The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
88.8
Style
91 %
Comfort
88 %
Fit
89 %
Brand
86 %
Value
90 %
Price Comparison Last Updated (16.09.19)
Amazon Link
$49.95
#6
The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
84.2
Style
84 %
Comfort
87 %
Fit
84 %
Brand
82 %
Value
84 %
Price Comparison Last Updated (16.09.19)
Amazon Link
$30.39
#7
The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
82
Style
84 %
Comfort
82 %
Fit
81 %
Brand
83 %
Value
80 %
Price Comparison Last Updated (16.09.19)
Amazon Link
$38.00
#8
The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
80.2
Style
82 %
Comfort
82 %
Fit
79 %
Brand
81 %
Value
77 %
Price Comparison Last Updated (16.09.19)
Amazon Link
$24.98
#9
The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
76
Style
74 %
Comfort
79 %
Fit
77 %
Brand
76 %
Value
74 %
Price Comparison Last Updated (16.09.19)
Amazon Link
$76.30
#10
The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
71.4
Style
70 %
Comfort
71 %
Fit
74 %
Brand
72 %
Value
70 %
Price Comparison Last Updated (16.09.19)
Amazon Link
$34.95

10 Best Shoes for Prom

1. Katy Perry The Stella

The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
95.8
Katy Perry The Stella
Amazon Link
Style
97
Comfort
98
Fit
95
Brand
94
Value
95
best offer for today
Amazon Link
$38.95
Pros:

Star Design

Slip-On

Two Color Options

3.5" Heel

Cons:

Sizes run large

The Katy Perry The Stella is an ultra-styled shoe that’s perfect for prom night. It features a brilliant all-over star pattern that looks great on the dancefloor and boasts thin high heel. Its comfortable slip-on design makes this shoe a user-favorite, and it’s available in two colors: white and black.

Read more

The Stella is available in two colors: white and black. The white version comes with multi-colored pastel colors on the stars, while the black comes with gold stars. You can make these shoes work with almost any outfit that you choose for prom.

The 3.5" heel might be a little higher than some are comfortable walking in, but the secure upper that fits all the way up to the ankle will help those who might need a little more security while walking in high heels.

2. Bolano Lawson

The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
92.2
Bolano Lawson
Amazon Link
Style
91
Comfort
92
Fit
94
Brand
90
Value
94
best offer for today
Amazon Link
$59.99
Pros:

Dual-Color

Synthetic Materials

Front Laces

Fabric Lining

Cons:

Narrow Fitting

The Bolano Lawson is a wingtip Oxford shoe with synthetic materials and a manmade outsole. It features fabric lining and a two-color design for a stylish look. The Oxford has a front lace-closure system for a secure fit and is available in a wide range of colors including, red, blue, pink, and pearl.

Read more

The Bolano Oxford features a dual-colored upper for a stylish look and includes a front lace closure system for more secure wear. These shoes feature fabric lining that's soft and comfortable, along with synthetic materials that are lightweight and airy.

Choose from a wide range of colors including red, pearl, white, baby blue, royal blue, and pink, to name a few. The Bolano Lawson is a truly unique pair of shoes that allows the wearer a chance to let their personality shine by expressing their creativity.

3. Enzo Romeo Kinmi25N

The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
91.2
Enzo Romeo Kinmi25N
Amazon Link
Style
93
Comfort
90
Fit
91
Brand
92
Value
90
best offer for today
Amazon Link
$31.99
Pros:

2.75-inch Heel Height

Rhinestone Glitter

Open Toe

Low-Heel

Cons:

Size runs big

This low heeled open-toed heel sandal is a great option for a prom shoe. Coming in 3 colors, you can choose the option that best fits your dress while still having a bit of your own personality shining through.

Read more

If you are looking for a manageable heel height, this pair gives you 2.75 inches of easy walking. Although still considered a mid-heel, it is low enough that you won't feel too wobbly on your feet if you're not used to stilettos.

Sparkling beauty glistens with each and every step you take under the prom night lights. Elegance with this pair will surely set you apart among the rest.

4. Enzo Romeo Lime03N

The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
89.6
Enzo Romeo Lime03N
Amazon Link
Style
90
Comfort
88
Fit
89
Brand
90
Value
91
best offer for today
Amazon Link
$31.99
Pros:

0.25-inch Platform Height

Gladiator Style

Rear Zipper Closure

Rhinestone

*1.5-inch Heel Height

Cons:

Size runs big

The picture does not do this justice, as these are very sparkly and will set off that dress wonderfully. Furthermore, the mid heel is a perfect size to help you keep stability, as the night of your prom wears on. In addition, the gladiator style is gorgeous and the rear zipper closure aids in maintaining a secure fit. At the end of the day, this is one pair that will let you stand out amidst the crowd.

Read more

Not too tall, this platform height helps to stabilize and give you a bit of height, in addition to the *1.5-inch approximated mid-heel. Moreover, you can feel great wearing these.

With this styling, you can wear this pair more than once. That is, after the prom, you can wear these with jeans or nearly anything else you can fancy of your choosing.

5. ElegantPark D'Orsay

The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
88.8
ElegantPark D'Orsay
Amazon Link
Style
91
Comfort
88
Fit
89
Brand
86
Value
90
best offer for today
Amazon Link
$49.95
Pros:

1-inch Platform Height

3.5-inch Heel Height

Rubber Outsole

Satin Upper

Pleated w/Rhinestone Chaining

Cons:

Size runs big

A stunning entrance cannot begin to describe you, as you walk into the room with these peep-toe and pleated-satin D'Orsay pumps. They are toned down with just a hint of rhinestone chaining running the length vertically. Although you were sparkle, it will not be loud. This, in turn, allows the satin gorgeousness to enhance your dress all that more. Moreover, you will feel great wearing these.

Read more

This satin upper is pleated and helps to define elegance in a way that will enhance your wardrobe choice. It is subtle, yet powerful. Moreover, this design is very classy.

This pair comes with extra heel tips and gel insoles. In addition to not having to purchase more heel tips, you can gain a bit more comfort which will help you to last the hours of an extended night. These fall into the upper end of the low-side of cost range. They are equipped with extra heel tips, gel insoles, and have an elegant beauty about them. This is one of those pairs which has a nice mix of sparkle and neutrality.

6. Bruno Marc Dress Oxford

The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
84.2
Bruno Marc Dress Oxford
Amazon Link
Style
84
Comfort
87
Fit
84
Brand
82
Value
84
best offer for today
Amazon Link
$30.39
Pros:

Genuine Leather

Latex Cushioned Footbed

Laces

Low Heel

Cons:

Strong out-of-box smell

The Bruno Marc Dress Oxford is a classic shoe made from genuine leather and designed in the USA. It features a low 1-inch wooden heel and a latex cushioned footbed for added comfort. The Oxford boasts front lace-up closures for a secure fit that won't slide while you're on the dancefloor and a burnished effect on the toes for a stylish look.

Read more

The Bruno Marc Dress Oxford is available in a variety of colors and styles including, black and brown, as well as, variation in styles. They come with-or-without laces and with variations to the toe box design.

The Dress Oxford is a comfortable dress shoe with a latex cushioned footbed that gives additional cushion and padding. The Oxford also features a low 1-inch heel that is functional enough to wear dancing for hours without having sore and fatigued feet.

7. Nina Cherie

The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
82
Nina Cherie
Amazon Link
Style
84
Comfort
82
Fit
81
Brand
83
Value
80
best offer for today
Amazon Link
$38.00
Pros:

Cushioned Insole

Leather Outsole

Fixed Bow

Rear Zipper

Cons:

Narrow

The Nina Cherie is a shootie style shoe with a 3.75-inch heel. It features a leather sole and slight cushioning for more comfortable wear. The Cherie is a stylish option that boasts a cute back zipper and fixed bow at the front. There are tons of colors available including black, white, red, grey, and blue.

Read more

The Cherie has a cushioned insole for more comfortable wear and features a slip-resistant leather outsole. Its back zipper allows for a snug fit so you won’t need to worry about your shoes fitting loosely.

These Nina shoes are a shootie style option that has a 3.75-inch heel and leather outsole. They boast a cute front fixed bow and are available in a variety of colors, including, white, black, red, blue, and grey.

8. GetMoreBeauty Lace Flower

The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
80.2
GetMoreBeauty Lace Flower
Amazon Link
Style
82
Comfort
82
Fit
79
Brand
81
Value
77
best offer for today
Amazon Link
$24.98
Pros:

Decorative Flower

4-inch Heel

Low Platform

Four Color Choices

Cons:

Narrow toe

The Lace Flower by GetMoreBeauty is a beautifully designed shoe that features a decorative lace flower along the side. It has a low ½-inch platform and 4-inch heel, along with a closed-toe design. You can choose from a variety of colors including, black, white, purple, and pink.

Read more

The Lace Flower is a stunning shoe for prom and is available in a range of color choices. It boasts an eye-catching decorative flower along the side and features a closed-toe design.

These GetMoreBeauty shoes include a low ½-inch platform for more functional wear and a sexy 4-inch heel. They are made from synthetic materials that are breathable and long-lasting and are available in an array of sizes.

9. Badgley Mischka Jewel

The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
76
Badgley Mischka Jewel
Amazon Link
Style
74
Comfort
79
Fit
77
Brand
76
Value
74
best offer for today
Amazon Link
$76.30
Pros:

Jeweled Ankle Stap

Buckle Closure

3-inch Heel

Leather

Synthetic Sole

Cons:

Sizes run small

The Badgley Mischka Jewel is an exquisite pair of shoes. They feature jeweled ankle and toe straps, along with a 3-inch heel. The Jewel boasts extra padding for comfortable wear and is made from leather with a synthetic sole.

Read more

The Jewel is a beautiful pair of shoes for prom, thanks to its jeweled ankle and toe straps it gleams under every light. It features a 3-inch heel which is high enough to look great while remaining practical enough.

These Badgley Mischka’s are as comfortable as they are hot thanks to an extra cushioned footbed. Your feet won’t be exhausted after a night out in these heels.

10. V-Luxury 32-ANGEL37

The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
71.4
V-Luxury 32-ANGEL37
Amazon Link
Style
70
Comfort
71
Fit
74
Brand
72
Value
70
best offer for today
Amazon Link
$34.95
Pros:

2.75-inch Heel Height

0.25-inch Platform Height

Patent Leather

Rhinestone

Cushioned Insole

Cons:

Size Runs Small

Patent leather and rhinestones set this pair up for a night worthy of the prom. Furthermore, they have a 2.75-inch heel height and 0.25-inch platform height. The wide band of ankle strap helps to both secure a better fit and add to the visual beauty of these. They are elegant and will match nearly any dress you choose for the big night. Moreover, these are made to sparkle while dancing under the lights of your life.

Read more

These are very sparkly and will stand out under changing lighting scenes. They adorn the feet well and will enhance your wardrobe stylings the same.

The heel height is a mid-heel and will work great for the night of your life. With 2.75 inches, you can gain a little extra height without overdoing it. This is a budget-friendly pair and will look good with many wardrobe choices. They are very sparkly and will shine a lot while you walk. This means if you want to stand out, then this is the pair for you.

Criteria Used for Evaluation

Style

For girls, fashion is this humongous part of prom, and the shoes you choose to wear are a crucial aspect of piecing together the perfect outfit. There are many types of shoes to wear for prom including:

Low-heel: Shoes with a low-heel height are better suited for individuals who feel less comfortable walking in sky-high shoes and are looking for more functionality. For a pump to be considered to have a low-heel height, it should be between one to 3.75-inches.

High-Heel: High heels usually consist of any pair of shoes with a heel-height above four inches. While these kind of heels are super sexy, they are also not the most practical choice for everyone. If you feel comfortable walking in high-heels than all the power to you, but if you haven’t in the past than it’s probably best not to start by wearing them on prom night.

Stiletto: Stilettos are high-heels only with a more pointed heel. This type of shoe is harder to walk in and if you’re inexperienced than prom is probably not the best place to be wearing this style of heel.

Flat: Flat shoes have no heel and no platform, they sit completely low to the ground. Many people think that flat shoes aren’t good enough to wear to occasions that require dress attire, but that just isn’t true. There are lots of stylish flats that look as good as a pair of heels only offers much more practicality.

Open-toe: A open-toed shoe can be any of the above styles, this simply means that there is no material covering your toes.

Closed-toe: A closed-toe shoe could also be any of the styles mentioned above only with a piece of material covering over your toes.

For boys, there are quite a few style variation of prom shoes including:

Slip-on: Slip-on shoes are the most popular choice of men for prom. This style of dress shoe has no closure system and is easy to slip on and off.

Lace-up: Some men’s dress shoes include a lace-up closure system. This makes for a much more custom and cozy fit and can also add a sophisticated style, although laces are not necessary.

Zippered: Men's dress shoes can have a zipper on the side, front, or back which is usually ore for style than functionality.

Flat: Flat shoes have no heel or platform. Some find these dress shoes challenging to wear, in part because their pants may drag along the floor.

Heel: When we use the term ‘heels’ about men’s shoes we aren’t talking about the same kind of height as with women’s heels, but rather between a one-to-two-inch chunky heel.

Another style consideration is the height of your shoe’s platform. Opting for a low platform is a better choice for those who are less comfortable walking high in the air and is better for people who are taller. A lower platform will give you better control over your footing and prevent accidental slips or falls from happening and let’s face it, no one wants to slip and fall down on prom night.

Comfort

Comfort is a significant factor to consider when choosing a pair of shoes for prom. Both guys and girls will spend the better part of the night up on their feet dancing to their favorite beats. While this is all fine and dandy, it can become a severe problem if the shoes you’re wearing start to hurt your feet. Sore feet can quickly ruin a prom and make you regret not considering comfort when selecting your footwear.

Things like a padded footbed, or soft lining materials will help prevent fatigue and limit the chances of rubbing which leads to painful blisters. It’s also essential that your shoes fit correctly because shoes that are too big will flop and can cause blisters, while ones that are too small can pinch your toes and cut-off circulation.

Try opting for a pair of shoes made from synthetic materials which are soft and breathable as these will cause fewer problems down the road. Synthetic materials are also more breathable and will keep your feet more cool and dry, which can help to prevent slips caused by moist feet that slide around in the shoe. A cushioned footbed is always recommended when possible to prevent foot fatigue and pain. You should also beware of the type of straps and closures your shoes have, making sure that they do not rub or press in a particular area that could lead to cuts or blisters.

Fit

It’s important to factor into your final decision, the wearability of a shoe. Prom night involves a lot of dancing and will be spent mostly on your feet; therefore, you don’t want a pair of shoes that are going to leave you unable to move around on the dancefloor. For example, if you’re uncomfortable walking in shoes with a high-heel than don’t opt for a pair just because you think that they’ll look right, this will leave you unable to enjoy yourself and move about freely because you don't know how to properly walk in high heels.

Likewise, if a shoe has a very narrow toe, you might think they look like something from a fairytale but in reality, could end up being your worst nightmare. If you have more full feet than opt for an appropriate shoe that is going to provide your toes with the room they need to not cramp and pinch them, doing so will save you all sorts of pain. If you absolutely must wear a pair of sky-high heels with itty-bitty toes, then at the very least bring yourself a pair of flats to slip into now and then. Bring a pair of comfortable shoes to escape into from time to time can save you quite a bit of grief and can allow your feet enough periodic reprieve that they should be okay for the better part of the night.

Choosing a pair of shoes that have a closure system such as laces, or a buckle can also help your shoes to stay in place which will lessen the chance of slipping, as well as, lower the probability of getting a getting an unpleasant blister.

Brand

When it comes to fashion and footwear, the brand behind the design plays an integral role. Everywhere you turn these days including newspapers, magazines, and on television, we see celebrities and Hollywood’s A-listers, wearing exquisite footwear. In music lyrics and rap songs, we continuously hear the artist make mention of fashion giants like Gucci, Prada, and Louboutin. It’s all about flaunting your fancy things. So with this sort of influence, it’s only natural for kids to want to fit in and to be a part of this lavish lifestyle.

However, they are just kids, so splurging on a high-end designer brand isn't always in their (or their parent's) budget.

The pairs featured on this list are perfect for prom in that they look fashionable while maintaining a price tag that won't break the bank (we'll go more into that in our next section).

Kids won't feel like they're missing out when they choose from one of the pairs on our list. You can rest assured that we've looked for the best brands for this price range and have taken into consideration a high schooler's opinions and budget.

Value

The last criteria that we would like to share are regarding the value. Here’s the deal, no one wants to spend above their budget on a shoe, especially one they might only wear once. So, when we were evaluating items, we really took into consideration a few different things when it comes to price. Primarily, we really wanted to focus on sharing brands and products that offered a blend of a good price tag with great value.

To do this, we looked at the price range and came up with an average or an estimated market value. This number was then used in choosing the best products. For example, we would look at a product and ask ourselves:

  • How is this priced in comparison to the estimated market price?
  • Does this product offer value equal to or greater than its price tag?
  • How does this compare to the other products we have selected?
  • Does the consumer receive more or less value from this than another brand?
  • No matter the type of shoe you are planning on purchasing, by asking questions like above, it can really help to ensure you are receiving your money’s worth for a purchase.

    Expert Interviews & Opinions

    Most Important Criteria (According to our experts opinion)
    Sort criterias acording to:
    Experts Opinion Editors Opinion Users Opinion By Default
    Click on a to rate the most important criteria:
    #1
    ico Style
    Rate This Criteria as Most Important
    #2
    ico Comfort
    Rate This Criteria as Most Important
    #3
    ico Fit
    Rate This Criteria as Most Important
    #4
    ico Brand
    Rate This Criteria as Most Important
    #5
    ico Value
    Rate This Criteria as Most Important
    expert tips icon
    Style For Prom Night

    It's that once in a lifetime night, where you and your friends dress to the nines, and go out to strut your stuff.
    When selecting your shoes, you can always make a statement with brighter colors or embellishments. If you're going for a classic look, keep them simple but sophisticated in style design.

    Tips For Prom

    To get the most out of your evening, a few fun things you can do to have a great time include:
    -Renting a limo- This lets you stress less about driving!
    -Go out for dinner- This gets you fed and fueled for dancing, and sets a great start to the evening
    -Let your friends know where you are- For safety, it's always good to have someone you can contact should something not go to plan.
    -Change of shoes- Just in case those high heels get too sore for you! Pack a pair of foldable flats or flip flops to take along with you.

    Other Factors to Consider

    Bottom Line

    That brings us to the end of our list of the best shoes for prom and hopefully, you are now that much closer to finding the perfect pair shoes. Keep in mind, that while looking good is an integral part of prom night, it's equally as important to enjoy your time spent with friends and loved ones too. When you are shopping, don't make impulsive decisions based strictly on how something looks, but take the time to consider other factors such as comfort, functionality, and overall wearability. If you include all of those factors into your final decision, you will find that you're much more satisfied with your selection overall and that you will enjoy your prom much more so than if you had chosen a pair of uncomfortable shoes.

    Frequently Asked Questions

    q: What are the best shoes for prom?

    a:

    No one shoe is the best shoe for prom. The best shoe for you will depend on many factors including, your ability to walk in high-heeled shoes, the width of your foot, and the platform height that you feel the most comfortable wearing. There are many other factors including styles, glitter, rhinestones, and accents that make up a prom shoe which will be different for everyone.

    q: Where can I buy shoes for prom?

    a:

    You can buy shoes for prom either in-store or online. Buying your shoes online has the added benefit of saving you quite a bit of money. Retail stores tend to charge a much higher price for the same item you could purchase online for a fraction of the cost.

    q: Can I wear my shoes from prom for other events too?

    a:

    The great thing about prom shoes is that they’re dressier style shoes and will be appropriate for all sorts of formal occasions, including, weddings, interviews, dates, and much more.

    q: How can I pick the best pair of prom shoes for myself?

    a:

    Only you know yourself best which means that you’re going to have to determine the best shoes based on some factors, including heel height, type of closure, materials, style, and design. When choosing a pair of shoes that you will be dancing in, always opt for as comfortable of wear as possible to prevent blisters and other aches and pains.

    q: Which color shoes go well with any outfit?

    a:

    Black and white are the two shades that match well with practically every color and are the safest options if you are undecided about your outfit. If you purchase a pair of either black or white shoes, you can still change your mind about your gear without having to worry about a new pair of shoes.

    q: Will flat shoes look bad with my dress?

    a:

    Absolutely not, in fact, there are many flat or low-heeled shoes that look just a good with a dress as any pair of high heels. It all comes down to your own style preferences and you should always dress the way that makes you happy and never worry about what others are going to think.

    q: I’m a girl but I prefer some of the styles of shoes for boys can I make it work if I wear a pair of guys dress shoes?

    a:

    Absolutely! No one ever said that girls need to wear heels and a dress to look beautiful, and vice-versa for boys with tuxedos and ties. Wear whatever makes you comfortable because your happiness is truly important and you will look good in whatever style of shoes or clothing that you choose to wear.

    Sources

    1. Steve Madden, Prom Shoes & Prom Heels, Product Information Page
    2. Davids Bridal, Shoes: Style Inspiration, Tips, & Trends 2018, Product Information Page
    3. Macy's , Prom Shoes 2018, Product Information Page
    4. 6pm, Prom Shoes, Product Information Page