to top 10 table

Best Lace Up Heels Reviewed & Rated

last updated Mar 05, 2019

Regular shoes such as running shoes, loafers, or sneakers tend to be designed for everyday use, whether casual or formal. However, lace-up stilettos focus more on style than function and tend to be open-toed, expose a lot of the foot, offer a great amount of elevation, and overall complete your chosen outfit. To do all of this, they need to be made with care with only the best materials. All parts of the shoe need to support the foot and also need to add a bit of comfort. This can be troublesome with any type of heel.

In a Hurry? The test winner after 11 hrs of research

icon
Kenneth Cole Barlow
94.4/100 our score
Style
93
Comfort
92
Materials
98
Ease of Use
93
Value
96
Kenneth Cole Barlow
Why is it better?

Leather Upper

Synthetic Sole

Back Zipper

Non-Marking Outsole

Quality Make

In a Hurry? Editors choice:
Kenneth Cole Barlow
Test Winner: Kenneth Cole Barlow
Amazon Link
Researched Sources
10
Researched Sources
Reviews Considered
1390
Reviews Considered
Hours Researching
11
Hours Researching
Products Evaluated
20
Products Evaluated
Sorting Options
Style Comfort Materials Ease of Use Value By Default
Rank
PictureProduct
Name
Rating
Shops
#1
The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
94.4
Style
93 %
Comfort
92 %
Materials
98 %
Ease of Use
93 %
Value
96 %
Price Comparison Last Updated (17.09.19)
Amazon Link
$49.99
#2
The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
91.4
Style
90 %
Comfort
94 %
Materials
92 %
Ease of Use
90 %
Value
91 %
Price Comparison Last Updated (17.09.19)
Amazon Link
$14.99
#3
The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
89.6
Style
90 %
Comfort
91 %
Materials
90 %
Ease of Use
89 %
Value
88 %
Price Comparison Last Updated (17.09.19)
Amazon Link
$78.87
#4
The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
88.8
Style
89 %
Comfort
87 %
Materials
91 %
Ease of Use
89 %
Value
88 %
Price Comparison Last Updated (17.09.19)
Amazon Link
$22.00
#5
The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
87
Style
89 %
Comfort
88 %
Materials
86 %
Ease of Use
87 %
Value
85 %
Price Comparison Last Updated (17.09.19)
Amazon Link
$27.99
#6
The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
85.8
Style
87 %
Comfort
88 %
Materials
84 %
Ease of Use
86 %
Value
84 %
Price Comparison Last Updated (17.09.19)
Amazon Link
$119.68
#7
The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
85.2
Style
86 %
Comfort
89 %
Materials
85 %
Ease of Use
83 %
Value
83 %
Price Comparison Last Updated (17.09.19)
Amazon Link
$29.00
#8
The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
80
Style
77 %
Comfort
80 %
Materials
82 %
Ease of Use
81 %
Value
80 %
Price Comparison Last Updated (17.09.19)
Amazon Link
$36.00
#9
The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
79.2
Style
84 %
Comfort
83 %
Materials
77 %
Ease of Use
76 %
Value
76 %
Price Comparison Last Updated (17.09.19)
Amazon Link
$19.50
#10
The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
76.4
Style
79 %
Comfort
76 %
Materials
74 %
Ease of Use
78 %
Value
75 %
Price Comparison Last Updated (17.09.19)
Amazon Link
$89.98

Top 10 Lace Up Heels

1. Kenneth Cole Barlow

The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
94.4
Kenneth Cole Barlow
Amazon Link
Style
93
Comfort
92
Materials
98
Ease of Use
93
Value
96
best offer for today
Amazon Link
$49.99
Pros:

Leather Upper

Synthetic Sole

Back Zipper

Non-Marking Outsole

Quality Make

Cons:

Expensive

Speaking of high-quality brands, we are eager to share another quality brand known for their masterful craftsmanship and quality designs. Let’s talk about the Kenneth Cole New York Barlow Dress Pump, a trusted brand with years of experience in the premium and luxury marketplace.

Read more

As we said earlier, one of the best features of quality brands is when they design their items with specialty features that ensure maximum comfort. One of the best features of this particular product is the back zipper feature which is designed and intended to make taking off and putting on the shoe easily.

As we said earlier, this brand is known for its quality products. Therefore, we would expect nothing different about this item. Designed for comfort and quality appearance, individuals have three different color choices to choose from. Choose between rose gold, blue, and a grey material that ensures masterful quality.

2. Report Laxy Platform

The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
91.4
Report Laxy Platform
Amazon Link
Style
90
Comfort
94
Materials
92
Ease of Use
90
Value
91
best offer for today
Amazon Link
$14.99
Pros:

Synthetic Upper

Lightly Padded

Back Zipper

Stable Platform

Cons:

Expensive

Now that we have shared a wide variety of shoes, we want to introduce a brand that has cut the price of their footwear by close to 70%. With that said, right now is the time to buy the Report Women’s Laxy Platform Dress Sandal which is comfortable and also very stylish.

Read more

Much like premium brands, this brand has designed these high heels with an easy entry zipper feature. This feature allows a person to easily take off and wear shoes. With that said, we recommend them for their comfort, style, and quality appearance.

Part of what makes these shoes one of the best in the industry is the fashion feel, which is also comfortable. With that said, the back is not as thin as many other styles, and the insole is lightly padded for an easy to wear experience.

3. Franco Sarto Darlis

The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
89.6
Franco Sarto Darlis
Amazon Link
Style
90
Comfort
91
Materials
90
Ease of Use
89
Value
88
best offer for today
Amazon Link
$78.87
Pros:

Leather or Suede Upper

2.5” Heel

Cushioned Footbed

Simple Laces

Versatile Style

Cons:

Laces Untie

Low Cut Toe

The perfect pair for a day to night look, the Franco Sarto Darlis will allow you to comfortably go to the office, and be ready for drinks afterward. Available in a variety of colors, it allows you to get the option that fits your wardrobe and preferences best, while the simple lace closure eliminates the hassle that most other similar foot apparel comes with.

Read more

The upper of the Darlis comes in both leather and suede, allowing you to go with whichever you prefer. While the genuine leather is going to be easier to care for, suede is known to be more supple, allowing a better fit. Whichever you go with, you’ll be happy to hear this is a piece of footwear that comes in three widths: narrow, medium and wide for a variety of foot shapes.

With a 2.5” heel, the Darlis is perfectly comfortable for prolonged wear. Not only that, but it will also put less pressure on the ball of your foot, preventing metatarsal and bunion issues, even if you wear it daily.

With an average cost, the Franco Sarto Darlis is an affordable pair of sensible footwear that is the perfect combination of unique and classic. The cutouts on the heel portion show a bit more skin, while the pointed toe keeps the line of the leg elongated and elegant for a variety of occasions.

4. J. Adams Gladiator

The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
88.8
J. Adams Gladiator
Amazon Link
Style
89
Comfort
87
Materials
91
Ease of Use
89
Value
88
best offer for today
Amazon Link
$22.00
Pros:

Intricate Cutouts

Stiletto Heel

Full Lace Closure

Back Zipper

Cons:

Flimsy Design

Cheap Materials

If you're after a pair of ankle boots with an open toe design that you can comfortably wear even in high temperatures, the Gladiator by J. Adams is the perfect option for you. Featuring intricate cutouts that show off some skin and allow for a good amount of breathability, this is a pair of footwear that'll look good with anything, especially considering the high stiletto heel that's elegant and daring.

Read more

The unique design of these particular heels comes in three different color choices. The most common is the Whiskey Suede color, which is a bright red and purple design that is striking and beautiful. The other two colors are more subdued colors such as the black and the tan leather design.

J Adams has grown to one of the biggest fashion empires in the world for beauty, simple design, and modern, unique elements. With that in mind, this brand is quality trusted and ensures satisfaction guaranteed.

5. Top Moda Table 8

The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
87
Top Moda Table 8
Amazon Link
Style
89
Comfort
88
Materials
86
Ease of Use
87
Value
85
best offer for today
Amazon Link
$27.99
Pros:

4.5" Heel

1" Platform

Breathable

Rear Zipper

Cons:

Will Show Signs of Wear

Cheap Materials

Our favorite thing about a pair of platform shoes is that they provide excellent amounts of elevations, without the discomfort that comes with a really high heel. These next sandals are designed with comfort in mind for individuals that love the stiletto look. With a cool design and plenty of colors to choose from, let’s talk about the Top Moda Table 8 Peep Toe, a stylish feel for any individual.

Read more

Nothing is more uncomfortable than wearing foot apparel that does not have an easy off or put on design. Well, the design of this particular style includes a rear zipper design that ensures an individual can wear these all day long comfortable and take them off easily when need be.

When it comes to brands that have an attention to detail mentality. This is one of the best, with that in mind, we can say that part of the quality of these shoes ensures attention to detail that is unprecedented. For example, this model has a stitching accent contrast design that makes them highly appealing.

6. Chinese Laundry Sylvia

The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
85.8
Chinese Laundry Sylvia
Amazon Link
Style
87
Comfort
88
Materials
84
Ease of Use
86
Value
84
best offer for today
Amazon Link
$119.68
Pros:

Leather Upper

Comfortable Shaft

Supportive Heel

Round Toe

Fully Adjustable

Cons:

Fluctuating Price

A unique looking lace-up boot style by Chinese Landry, this is a pair that'll set you apart in a crowd. Whether you decide to wear them with jeans or a dress, they'll draw the compliments of your peers, while the quality combined with the affordable price will make you want to go out and purchase a pair right away.

Read more

One unique aspect of these particular boots is that they are made from 100% leather. Designed for unique comfort and aesthetic style, women will appreciate the authentic leather material construction that ensures maximum durability and quality.

Now, this particular brand only offers these shoes in two color choices. With that said, the first color is a plum and black leather material while the second color is a brushed suede rose pink that has a stitched rose on the side of it. With that said, both styles are intended to be worn with particular outfits and will enhance any evening look.

7. Soda Korman

The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
85.2
Soda Korman
Amazon Link
Style
86
Comfort
89
Materials
85
Ease of Use
83
Value
83
best offer for today
Amazon Link
$29.00
Pros:

Supportive Style

Made in the USA

Rubber Outsole

Chunky Heel

Great for Cold Weather

Cons:

Bulky

This next item is designed with a bold look that will turn heads at any party or event. With plenty of different color choices to choose from, we want to talk about the Soda Korman. This product is designed with quality materials in mind to ensure maximum support and comfort. With that said, here are two unique features.

Read more

If you are not a fan of thin stilettos because of what may happen to your ankle with them on, then we highly recommend this quality item. The back is one of the thickest styles around and is designed for better support while also toning your legs and your back. With that said, the inside is comfortable and offers better ankle support as well.

One unique aspect of this particular style is that they come in a large variety of colors. This style comes in black, ruby, grey, and many tan color choices. With this, an individual can collect them all and match them to any outfit.

8. J. Adams Cady

The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
80
J. Adams Cady
Amazon Link
Style
77
Comfort
80
Materials
82
Ease of Use
81
Value
80
best offer for today
Amazon Link
$36.00
Pros:

Synthetic Materials

4” Heel

Decorative Tassels

Handcrafted

Inexpensive

Cons:

Tall Heel

With a long tradition of making great shoes, J. Adams has yet again made a great pair of footwear - something its price is a testament to as well. The Cady is a pair of open-toed booties made for an unexpected peep of skin that works wonders on warm spring and autumn days when you may want to show off your favorite pair of unique footwear that oozes with style and quality.

Read more

As with all J. Adams shoes, the Cady is also handcrafted by professionals who use only the highest quality materials. Not only does this ensure that your expensive foot apparel will last a lifetime, but you can also expect them to be incredibly comfortable as well as perfectly balanced for a pain-free wearing experience.

Using kid suede in the upper, leather lining and leather laces, the Cady is a great pair of boots that will mold to your foot, give it just the right amount of protection, and allow it to breathe to prevent moisture pooling. Whether you plan on wearing it with hosiery or barefoot, you can rest assured it won’t cause any blisters or hot spots.

9. Steve Madden President

The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
79.2
Steve Madden President
Amazon Link
Style
84
Comfort
83
Materials
77
Ease of Use
76
Value
76
best offer for today
Amazon Link
$19.50
Pros:

Padded Insole

Slip-Resistant Outsole

Stable Heel

Synthetic Materials

Padded Footbed

Cons:

Straps Ride Down

As one of the best brands online, this brand is high affordable, but their items are known for their quality and distinctive designs. Let’s talk about this sandal from Steve Madden. Many of our team members have purchased from this brand and have touted themselves the quality of the shipment. Here are two features of this foot apparel.

Read more

The design of this particular model boasts a unique open toe concept alongside a stylish but traditional appearance. With that said, they are perfect for a summer or spring outfit alongside a day of light walking. With plenty of colors to choose from, the design makes it a very beautiful design to wear.

This is the first brand on this list we can say has one of the best insole designs in the industry. The insole is padded for better comfort for an all-day wear experience. However, the outsole is also designed for comfort and durability. The outsole is a non-slip outsole designed for durability and safety.

10. Steve Madden Pampered

The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
76.4
Steve Madden Pampered
Amazon Link
Style
79
Comfort
76
Materials
74
Ease of Use
78
Value
75
best offer for today
Amazon Link
$89.98
Pros:

Chunky Heel

Great Ankle Stability

4.25” Height

Nubuck Upper

Synthetic Sole

Cons:

Synthetic Lining

Extremely High

Blush nubuck, a chunky high heel, and a curved insole, what more could a girl ask for? These amazing heels by Steve Madden are a beautifully designed pair of stilettos that go with some outfits, from suits to jeans, to formal gowns. Put them on for a night on the town, show them off at a formal wedding, or wear them to a casual office where you’ll get numerous compliments from colleagues and friends.

Read more

Even though the closure on this pair of pumps is thin and subtle, it’s placed in the perfect position to ensure a good amount of stability when you’re walking on the sky-high heel. With its well thought out position, you can rest assured that the Pampered is a piece of footwear that won’t slip or flop around, ensuring your safety.

Even though it’s 4 inches high, the heel on the Pampered is one of the most comfortable ones you’ll find on this list. This is mostly because it’s a chunky style with a larger surface, giving your heel better backing while preventing any possibility of getting stuck in a crack. Great for walking on cobblestone or grassy surfaces!

Criteria Used for Evaluation

Style

As you can see, there is a number of stilettos that come with lace closures, and you’ll have to make some difficult choices if you are to settle on just one pair. From pumps to boots, you’ll see that this is a popular trend, and there is hardly a brand that doesn’t have at least one pair of lace-up stilettos in their offer. But what you go with will not only depend on whether you like the design or not, it will also depend on how you plan on wearing your newly purchased shoes.

With that in mind, here are a few options:

  • Pumps - the most classic of the lot, pumps will be the perfect option for you if you’re thinking about wearing this type of footwear to the office, a formal event, or for going out. Available in a huge variety of heel heights as well as design variations, this list includes leather styles as well as ones with fabric or suede uppers for completely different looks that will work with different outfits. If you’re after something that’ll be most universally appropriate, then this is the type of shoe you should choose.
  • Sandals - more likely to be available in lace-up versions, sandals always look great with the additions of a few laces or tassels that bring attention to the leg without going overboard with decorations. Whether you opt for something chic for an elegant night or go with a more colorful, fun style, it’ll provide you with a great stylistic update.
  • Boots - finally, if you go with high heeled boots, chances are you’re going to get them either with a zipper or lace closure (or even both). Boots on this list include both winter specific styles that are great for the colder months as they offer a good combination of weather protection and style, as well as open-toed models with various cutouts that are more casual, but look amazing with a variety of outfits, including skinny jeans.
  • Comfort

    One of the biggest benefits of a lace closure on any type of footwear is the fact that it allows for an excellent level of fit adjustability, something that anyone with a foot that’s more narrow or wide than the standard will greatly appreciate. Even more, if you’ve got a high instep, or you find that your feet have swollen after a long day of standing, you can easily loosen or tighten the laces, and you’ll be good to go.

    But, in addition to this adjustability factor, it is also important to consider whether the very construction of the shoe you’re purchasing is comfortable enough. There are several things that may contribute to your wearing experience, the toe and the footbed being the biggest ones.

    Seeing that stilettos put your feet in an unnatural position, shifting your entire body weight, you need to know that bearing all of your weight on the balls of your feet can become quite painful after a couple of hours, even with the most expensive shoes available. That’s why, when shopping, you should invest either in style with a padded footbed, or purchase separate inserts that can put a bit of cushioning between your feet and the ground. Even more, if you can find a shoe with some level of arch support, or a more stable heel, these can greatly contribute to how you will feel after some time wearing them.

    Secondly, the toe of your shoe is in charge of how it will fit in the front, and whether you will have enough room to balance properly, or if your foot will be crammed in a space that’s too small. The optimal choice is always to get a round toe shoe, although open-toed styles can also work well. If, however, you do decide to go with a pointed toe, you will need to consider whether the fit of the shoe allows enough comfort for you to be walking and standing properly. It’s important to keep in mind that forcing yourself into narrow shoes can escalate foot health issues such as blisters, corns, and even bunions, all of which can become difficult to treat, and some may even require surgery.

    Materials

    Because lace-up stilettos are made with more elements than regular ones, it’s crucial that they’re made well to stand the test of time, as well as to put up with the daily wear and tear. What will contribute to this the most is the type of materials used in the manufacturing process. If you’re looking for something you will regularly be wearing, it may be smart to invest in something that uses better materials than to force yourself to wear lower quality footwear.

    The first part of the shoe anyone will look at is the upper. Styles on this list include models made with leather, suede and textile, but manufacturers will often use synthetic materials as well, which can work if you need something more protective or durable. However, for optimum comfort results, it is better to go with natural materials as they should be able to form to your foot more easily, giving you a customized fit that won’t constrict or cause pain.

    Secondly, you’ll want to look at the outsole of your stilettos. High end and designer items may use leather in the sole, which is great for a sophisticated look, but it’s not the most versatile option. It can only be worn on a limited number of surfaces and will degrade if ever worn in the rain. Rubber and synthetics may work better in this case, especially seeing that a thicker layer of these materials may even provide a bit of shock absorption that could prevent muscle fatigue and joint pain that comes with lots of standing and walking.

    Finally, make sure that the shoes you purchase come with a quality lining and footbed, as this is the part of the footwear that’ll be in touch with your skin. If you have any allergies, you need to ensure your shoes don’t contain such materials. The best options for these include leather or moisture-wicking linings that’ll breathe well, allowing moisture to escape from your foot and preventing the development of bad odors.

    Other materials you may find in your high stilettos may include memory foam insoles or EVA foam footbeds, both of which are great additions if you’re after a more comfortable style that won’t cause pain in the long run.

    Ease of Use

    The truth about lace-up stilettos is that they can be a hassle, especially if we’re talking about a pair of high boots. To make sure you don’t start avoiding wearing your newest pair of stilettos, you should consider how many lace eyes there will be to tighten every day, and whether there are any alternative closure methods present.

    The best piece of advice we can give, if you’re going with a higher shaft, is to make sure the boot has a zipper closure that’ll allow easy on and off, without having to take time with lacing them up. Not only will this save you time, but it’ll ensure a proper fit every time you wear your shoes.

    Value

    Last but not least, you will want to invest your hard earned money in shoes that justify the cost. Regardless of your budget, the best options will always include a few key points: a fit that’s just right for you, a style that’s satisfactory for what you want to wear your shoes for, and quality make that’ll ensure your shoes last for a considerable amount of time.

    You’ll often find that styles made with more luxurious materials will cost considerably more, as will those designed by more popular brands. Nonetheless, it’s important to note that smaller companies can make shoes just as good, if not better, at a price that’s more affordable to the average person. When shopping, don’t just buy the latest shoe model because it’s new or popular - consider whether you really need it and whether you’ll wear it often enough to legitimate the cost.

    All the models on this list have been chosen because they provide adequate quality, and are good investments for those who plan on wearing them regularly. If, however, you’re looking for something to wear once or twice, you may want to consider going with something more budget-friendly, and keeping part of your money to spend on a shoe you’ll wear more often.

    Expert Interviews & Opinions

    Most Important Criteria (According to our experts opinion)
    Sort criterias acording to:
    Experts Opinion Editors Opinion Users Opinion By Default
    Click on a to rate the most important criteria:
    #1
    ico Style
    Rate This Criteria as Most Important
    #2
    ico Comfort
    Rate This Criteria as Most Important
    #3
    ico Materials
    Rate This Criteria as Most Important
    #4
    ico Ease of Use
    Rate This Criteria as Most Important
    #5
    ico Value
    Rate This Criteria as Most Important
    expert tips icon
    Leg Lengthening Looks

    Strappy lace up heels have a great quality for lengthening the look of your legs. In order to get this leggy look, pair your favorite pair of lace up heels with shorter skirt and dresses, or even a shorter romper, for a great look to take out on the town!

    Keeping High Heel Heights Comfortable

    Everyone loves a heel. The silhouette that it give the calf and legs, even wearing high heels that have a unique look can turn your feet into one of the most noticeable parts of your outfit. But, sometimes high heels can start to get uncomfortable after longer periods of wear.
    To keep you comfortable, invest in a pair of cushioned high heel insoles, which can give the forefoot a little extra padding when you're on your feet for the evening.

    Other Factors to Consider

    Brand

    There’s a wide variety of brands that offer lace up stilettos, so you’ll probably find a pair made by your favorite one. If, however, you’re looking to try something else, you can rest assured that all the models listed in this article are well made and are worth the investment.

    The great thing about products that are widely available is that they make the manufacturers think about ways in which they can stand out. While some may try to do this through price or design, others will do this by giving their customers better quality items that’ll not only last longer, but that may also provide better functionalities in terms of comfort, support or ease of use.

    Bottom Line

    If you want quality styles and have been looking for a while, what do you think of this great selection? Not only are some incredibly stylish and appealing, they are all designed for long-lasting wear and tare. Whether you are a designer brand, or you are looking for more professional designs, we hope we have satisfied your craving. With that in mind, it took a while to develop this specialized list. The reason being is that the industry is saturated with endless amounts of options.

    Frequently Asked Questions

    q: Is the insole cushioned?

    a:

    As the first question that individuals are asking, we can see why this is a crucial question because this style of footwear is known among some of the most uncomfortable shoes to wear all day long. Therefore, a cushioned insole aids in walking in them all day. With that in mind, we can say that the insole of many of the designs we have shared is designed to offer a slight cushion and some are even Tempurpedic. However, individuals should expect that most styles only offer a slight cushion and now a lot of it.

    q: Are they narrow or wide?

    a:

    As another key question that individuals are asking, the width of the shoe tends to be one of the most important aspects of the design and quality of the shoe. With that said, the rule of thumb is that the pointier the shoe, the more narrow it is. Also, if the back of the shoe tends to be thick, the width tends also to be wider.

    q: Do they make the clicking noise when walking?

    a:

    This is one of the most common questions that individuals are asking. When it comes to the clicking of the shoe, we can say that this is only most prevalent among very thin backs with a non-rubber bottom. With that said, individuals can muffle the sound by buying rubber bottoms and cushioning the stiletto a lot better.

    q: How do I clean the material?

    a:

    This question is also one of the most common. When cleaning the material, one of the most important aspects to consider is the material of the shoe. With that said, most pairs can be cleaned with a damp cloth.